Contract Free PR Support

  • The Waterline: What Marketing Consultants Should Still Get Paid For in the Age of AI

    The Waterline: What Marketing Consultants Should Still Get Paid For in the Age of AI written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    AI is coming for the strategy document. That sentence alone creates anxiety for a lot of consultants, strategists, and agencies. For years, many of us have sold research, audits, positioning exercises, customer personas, content plans, and full strategy documents as premium deliverables. Now, a business owner can sit down with an AI model and generate […]

    Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Robert Rose, founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute, about this year’s B2B content marketing research. The survey of more than eight hundred marketers confirms what a lot of teams already feel. AI made content faster and cheaper to produce, companies spent that speed on volume, and the people doing the work are stretched thinner than ever.

    Rose explains why AI output drifts toward the most probable answer, how that’s building what he calls a beige wall of content, and why leadership keeps missing the burnout on their dashboards. We also get into the quiet loss of entry-level roles, where all that grunt work actually lands, and why fifty-two percent of companies still have no AI disclosure policy.

    This one is for small business owners and marketing leaders trying to use AI for content without sanding their brand down to average. Rose shares a simple test for every piece you publish, the difference between getting mentioned and getting cited in AI answers, and why you have to understand your marketing process before you plug in any tool.

    Guest bio

    Robert Rose is the founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute. He has worked with more than five hundred brands in twenty-five countries, including Salesforce, SAP, and Adidas. Each year he writes CMI’s B2B content marketing research report, one of the most closely watched studies in the industry. Rose is also the coauthor of Killing Marketing with Joe Pulizzi.

    Key takeaways

    • AI delivered on speed and efficiency, and most companies spent the gain on more volume. Teams are busier, and the marketing isn’t getting better.
    • Leadership sees productivity gains while practitioners feel the burnout, and human training and headcount sit at the bottom of many 2027 budget lists.
    • AI content is the most probable answer to a prompt. Without someone who can recognize good work, output slides toward average over time.
    • When everyone publishes more of the same, the result is a beige wall that makes it harder for any brand to stand out.
    • Entry-level tasks that companies assumed AI would absorb are landing on mid-level and senior marketers instead.
    • Cutting the bottom rung of the career ladder removes the training ground where marketers develop taste. Intentional, even analog, mentoring may be the answer.
    • Agencies that price on value can use AI to deliver more for the same fee without racing to the bottom on price.
    • For every piece of content, ask where the human is: the person who knows the statistic, stands behind the claim, lived the customer story, or owns the anecdote.
    • Getting cited as a source in AI answers matters far more than getting mentioned, and citations come from podcasts, communities, industry press, and research.
    • Understand how your marketing gets made before adding AI. Treat it as an overlay on a defined process, the way you’d treat electricity.

    Great moments

    • [00:01] – Why AI made B2B content cheaper without making it better
    • [01:00] – Reuniting nearly ten years after Killing Marketing
    • [02:20] – The two biggest surprises in this year’s research
    • [04:24] – Business owners waiting for AI to replace their people
    • [05:10] – Why AI content is “most probable” and how that creates the beige wall
    • [07:04] – The disappearing bottom rung of the career ladder
    • [08:32] – Rose’s first job and the three-month reading assignment that taught him what good looks like
    • [09:29] – Teams as long-term investments and technology as day trading
    • [10:49] – Should agencies charge more for AI-assisted work?
    • [12:52] – Fifty-two percent of companies have no AI disclosure policy
    • [15:02] – Em dash backlash and why slop has always existed
    • [17:04] – The one question to ask about every piece of content
    • [19:06] – Getting mentioned vs. getting cited in AI answers
    • [20:23] – Why leaders need to understand their marketing process first
    • [21:28] – Replace “get good at AI” with “get good at electricity”

    Memorable quotes

    “A human team is an investment that grows in value over time the more you invest in it. Technology is day trading.” – Robert Rose

    “What AI content is, is the most probable. It is the most probable answer to your question or your prompt.” – Rose

    “We’ve always had slop. It’s just now AI has more of it.” – Rose

    “Only you can put the human in the story.” – Rose

    “Being mentioned and being cited are two very different content strategies.” – Rose

    John Jantsch (00:01.624)

    You know, because of AI, B2B marketers have built a content machine that runs faster than ever. But the newest research says that machine makes everything cheaper and nothing better. And the people operating it feel the strain while the people in charge of it can’t see it on their dashboard. The gap was confirmed across more than 800 marketers, and that’s what we’re going to talk about today, the results of that survey. Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch.

    My guest today is Robert Rose. He’s the founder of Seventh Bear and Chief Strategy Advisor to Content Marketing Institute. He’s worked with more than 500 brands across 25 countries, including Salesforce, SAP, and Adidas. And every year he writes CMI’s B2B Content Marketing Research Report. And this year, the numbers on AI speed and trust are why he’s on the show today. Plus, he’s a good guy. Hey, Robert.

    Robert Rose (00:56.331)

    How are you, my friend? It’s been far too long since we’ve been together.

    John Jantsch (01:00.302)

    Yeah, you know, I think, and you’re gonna be able to tell me when this was, that that the last time you were on my show is with with Joe, and you guys had written killing marketing or something.

    Robert Rose (01:12.948)

    killing marketing. Yeah. Yeah. Which would have been almost ten years now. That’s it was twenty sixteen or twenty seventeen. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (01:16.96)

    Okay, thanks.

    Well what a testament to us hanging around, huh?

    Robert Rose (01:23.035)

    Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And we have all the grey in our hair to prove it, so so

    John Jantsch (01:26.19)

    So I guess the I guess the first question is like, what did you get wrong in killing marketing? Like what what what is what has changed that made that like okay, if we’d have known that

    Robert Rose (01:38.496)

    Y well, I mean, you know, I mean, I know it’ll come up. It’s been maybe twenty five seconds since we’ve talked about AI, but but you know, of course, you know, we I don’t think I either of us were anticipating the disruption that AI would truly have on well, the world of business full stop. But certainly marketing has been the the focus with generative AI being at the center of that and you know, and how that is really affecting how we create valuable content, which of course is what killing marketing was all about.

    John Jantsch (02:07.544)

    So I I guess let’s just cut to the chase for those people that ha don’t have very long attention spans. what what what blew you away in this research this year? What’s like the one giant wow.

    Robert Rose (02:13.706)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (02:20.053)

    I you know, it was it was there was two giant wows, I think. one very positive and one you know, it it sounds like a negative at first, but I think it’s a big positive. And then the other, which is a negative that I think is a negative. And the first one is this idea that ostensibly AI has done what it meant to do or what the f you know, frontier models have all marketed us to do, which was we were promised in twenty two and twenty three.

    John Jantsch (02:24.27)

    Okay, okay.

    Robert Rose (02:46.527)

    That this was gonna remove the drudgery. We were gonna have all this time to do creative thinking and strategy and all this thing because AI was going to remove all that drudgery and it’s done the first part of that, right? It’s maked us faster and it’s made us more efficient. But what businesses have done with that speed and efficiency is just doubled up, doubled down on volume, right? And so we haven’t

    John Jantsch (03:06.496)

    Yeah. Yeah, I I talk to people all the time, they’re like, I’m working more than I ever was.

    Robert Rose (03:11.007)

    That’s exactly right. So we’re we’re creating double the amount of content now and you know and and and double the amount of effort. And then so that’s the the first sort of validating thing is is that it has not provided the quality or the you know the sort of value in making our marketing better, but it has made us busier as a result of it. And that’s sort of validating from a perspective of it feels that way, right? And you know, we the the gut feel is there. So it’s very validating. The second, which I think is probably the

    the the the negative one is the disparity between leadership and where the practitioners are in the business where senior leadership doesn’t see that right they’re they’re they’re seeing more productivity more efficiency and more speed and not seeing the burnout and not seeing the the you know the the the quality sort of slowly degrade and ultimately the last item on the twenty twenty seven budget list right now is human development, human skills training, human, you know, sort of headcount.

    And I think that’s a portend of of of very bad things to come if we don’t reinvest in human teams again.

    John Jantsch (04:17.602)

    Yeah, I mean you almost get the feeling from from some folks that they’re just waiting for AI to get good enough so they could get rid of their people.

    Robert Rose (04:24.105)

    Yeah, that’s right. That’s right. There I and and I’ve actually heard CMOs, I believe short sighted CMOs or even business owners in smaller and medium sized businesses say exactly that, right? You know, they’ve always seen marketing as kind of a tax. And so, you know, they’re just waiting for the robots to get good enough to replace the humans. And it’s like, boy, is that misguided.

    John Jantsch (04:44.248)

    You know, a year ago, we were probably still saying, like, how many people are using AI? you know, what’s the what’s the usage, you know, going on? And now it’s like everybody. you know, so that’s no longer a valid question, right? But what’s interesting, of course, you know, I I’m not sure I needed a survey to say this, but that that people are saying the quality, you know, still stinks. I mean, w why? You know, why does the quality stick?

    Robert Rose (05:10.719)

    I you know, I’ve been chalking it up to this. So look, we know there’s a lot of, you know, i in the early days, and even to some extent now, we get this sort of AI content is average, right? You know, we get this, you know, AI content is mediocre. And it’s like it’s not that’s technically not true. What AI content is is the most probable, right? It is the most probable answer to your question or your prompt. And most probable in some cases can be good. It can be clever, it can be really quite good.

    But it’s also what’s already existing, right? Because it has to be, because that’s what is most probable, is something that already exists in the world. And thus, if you don’t recognize what good looks like, in other words, if you as the human don’t understand that this is mediocre or this is fantastic, you end up averaging out over time. And so what’s happening is with that focus on speed and volume being the big thing.

    John Jantsch (05:43.885)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (05:54.263)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (06:05.385)

    Mo many businesses are just dumping more spaghetti against the wall and being surprised that less and less of it is actually sticking. And so it’s creating, I call it the beige wall, right? We’re we’re just creating this beige wall of content out there, which because everybody’s doing it, it means it’s even harder for us to get noticed, differentiated, and create distinctiveness in our own brand. Thus, what we’re really seeing is that degradation of quality content over time. And that’s just providing poorer.

    Poorer marketing efforts all the way around.

    John Jantsch (06:37.506)

    Yeah, but at least there’s more of it.

    Robert Rose (06:39.273)

    Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. It’s cheaper, right? You know, that’s the thing. It’s like if you look at it on a spreadsheet, it’s like, well, it’s cheaper to create. And it’s so that ROI is there because if it does anything, it’s actually making money. But it’s not actually making our marketing any better. It’s just making it cheaper and more commoditized.

    John Jantsch (06:56.894)

    Another statistic that that I think kind of jumped out at me is that people aren’t really pointing to efficiencies.

    Robert Rose (07:04.509)

    No. No. That’s that, you know, that’s that. Well, you know, cause that and that gets to your point where you were saying, you that you’re hearing a lot of like, well, we’ll just wait for the AI to get good enough to basically replace people. What’s happening is we can see this in so many businesses, small, medium, and large enterprises, people are cutting off the lower rung of the career ladder, right? So all of the young people, interns, inexperienced people, we are those are the ones that are getting assumed with the, you know, with the tasks.

    John Jantsch (07:24.344)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (07:32.159)

    You know, that AI will now take over and so they’re just not getting hired. But what the research showed us is that those tasks are not getting subsumed into AI. They’re actually just getting moved further up the career ladder. In other words, mid-level and senior level people are actually having to do all that work now. So they’re the ones that now get the email from the CEO saying, I know you’re busy. So I just had Claude whip up a white paper. Can you just do your magic on it and edit it for me? Right. So they’re busier than ever, doing more grunt work than ever.

    John Jantsch (07:45.486)

    Sure.

    John Jantsch (07:59.501)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (08:01.256)

    And it’s basically just because we don’t have the people or the skills or the you know the the the head count and the to be able to do it.

    John Jantsch (08:09.442)

    Yeah, and of course there’s a lot of a growing number of people. I’m not sure, you know, this this this involves investing in your people intentionally. And so I’m not sure it’s high on some people’s list. But there’s growing concern that, you know, you and I learned how to have taste and how to actually know what is good and what is bad by doing the groundwork. And and that’s like, where’s that training ground?

    Robert Rose (08:32.297)

    Hundred percent.

    Yeah, that’s exactly right. My first job, you know, and I tell this story in the research report. My first job was for a television network. And my first day on the job, my boss walked into me with a stack of industry magazines and basically said, Your first job is to read every single one of these and start to understand our industry jargon, to understand what we do for a living, and basically gave me a job of of of internally auditing all the things in the TV network. And it took me three months. It would take AI 16 minutes to do that same task.

    John Jantsch (09:03.842)

    Mm-hmm.

    Robert Rose (09:05.268)

    But what it did was it gave me a foundational education on what good actually looked like in the business and helped me be a better employee. And we’re just losing that we’re losing that developmental skill.

    John Jantsch (09:16.748)

    Yeah. So so I mean, does a company have to actually say, Okay, I know it’s very inefficient to make you read this stuff, but you have to? I mean, is it is that what it’s gonna take? Like a mentoring program that’s like analog? Yeah.

    Robert Rose (09:29.716)

    Yeah, I really do. I I believe in this. I believe that, you know, so look, my belief, and you know, maybe this is me being a little, you know, tilting at windmills or whatever, but but I I think my belief is is that a team, a human team, is an investment that grows in value over time the more you invest in it. Technology is day trading. Technology is whatever you did yesterday is only as good as what you put into it today. And so that transactional effort doesn’t actually

    Increase in value over time. In fact, it decreases in value over time. But your team, as it as it gets wisdom, as it gets experience, as it gets the ability to, you know, realize what discernment, you’re not only building the second layer of upper management that is invested in your business, you’re also building in wisdom and discernment into the marketing team itself so the team becomes better and it can transfer that knowledge to the new people who come in and so on and so forth. So it’s in,

    It’s an asset. The marketing team to me is an asset worth investing in. And technology is simply a tool that basically, you know, makes it makes it more efficient. And so investing in the latter is just literally triaging, you know, the day and trying to get, you know, some incremental increase in investment in a very short period of time, where the long term investment is people.

    John Jantsch (10:49.208)

    So I don’t think your research actually went into this idea, but you know, I have l contended, at least in my own business, that while we’re using AI and in and maybe, you know, it’s causing people to do more, if nothing else, causing them to learn how to use the AI tool, you know, as as part of their job. But I wanna I wanna contend that we are delivering more value to our clients for the same commitment, the same dollar amount.

    we are delivering more value. and I don’t know if we are looking at it that correctly, like should we be charging more? or, you know, is the client just benefiting from the fact that we know how to use this tool on their behalf?

    Robert Rose (11:31.627)

    I think the latter is the way I come down on it, which is I don’t buy into the zeitgeist of agencies are irrelevant anymore, certainly. And I don’t buy into the zeitgeist of that we should be charging less because we have AI tools to help us do our jobs, right? To make us more efficient. Because I’ve never believed in charging by the hour anyway, right? And so if we’re charging for value created, whether that’s, you know, there’s so many different models we could talk about in terms of the way that services are delivered, but if we’re chart, you know, if we’re basically saying,

    John Jantsch (11:49.518)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (12:01.298)

    It doesn’t matter how fast it takes us, what you’re what you’re what you’re, you know, what you’re being charged for, build for for us is the experience and the deliverable and the expertise and the quality of the thing that we’re delivering to you, no matter how fast or efficient we are at creating it. Then what you’re saying is basically we should be charging the same or more based on our ability to use the tool and an ability to create better work. And so that’s where I come down on this is that it is it is not about.

    you know, our AI forward, if you will, you know, sort of stance is not we’re more efficient, therefore we’re cheaper than the competition. It is that, yeah, sure, we use the tools, we use Photoshop, we use typewriters, we use computers, we use Xerox machines, we use electricity and lights and water, and we use all these technologies to make us better.

    John Jantsch (12:37.27)

    Is this?

    John Jantsch (12:48.491)

    a fax machine, throw that there, why not?

    Robert Rose (12:50.258)

    Yeah, the fax machine too. Yes, exactly.

    John Jantsch (12:52.43)

    I had the IRS wanted something from me, and the only way I could give it to them was to fax it to them. Can you believe that? Yeah. And unfortunately, it was a 200-page document, so have fun with that. That’s what you asked for. That’s what you got. So well, let’s go another direction. this doesn’t surprise me. In fact, I I find this shockingly low. 52% of companies have no disclosure policy, no governance, no

    Robert Rose (12:57.566)

    Yeah, I yes. It’s sadly it’s sad but true, yeah.

    Robert Rose (13:05.114)

    Yeah.

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (13:22.03)

    compliance, no whatever, on the legal side of it. In fact, most of the companies we end up working with, it’s pretty much bring your own device. yeah bring your own chat GPT account, you know, and go for it. I mean, are we in for a reckoning at some point on that, you think, or will this all settle down?

    Robert Rose (13:39.465)

    I think, well, you know, the interesting thing is, I think, you know, I’m not sure when this is gonna air, but the but over the last two weeks w I think we’ve seen the beginning of the reckoning of how some of that AI is being used, you know, with the FAA’s outage and and certainly with, you know, Microsoft’s outage and certainly with a lot of the outages that we’ve seen here, I think we’re going to come to find out. This is this is a prediction, I guess, or a hot take, if you will.

    John Jantsch (13:48.172)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (14:03.22)

    But I think we’re going to come to find out that a lot of this is sort of shortcuts in the way that we use AI to code and create patches for software and the sort of firing of engineering and all that sort of thing. That chicken is coming home to roost. similar things are happening in marketing as well. you know, and so and and the key there is is that disclosure policy, I think, and internal guidelines and standards are two different things, right? And so internal guidelines and standards are.

    John Jantsch (14:16.866)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (14:28.706)

    Mm-hmm.

    Robert Rose (14:32.73)

    100% needed and so low on most businesses’ priority lists because to your point, it’s bring your own device and figure it out, right? You know, bring your own chat GPT and figure it out. You know, I’ll use Gemini, they’ll use Chat GPT, they’re gonna use this, whatever, and never the twain shall meet. And so I think that changes over time and starts to get more governed, you know, and more governance and and and workflow to it. the disclosure policy, I think ultimately right now we’re in a weird place, right? Where

    John Jantsch (14:41.55)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (14:54.646)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (15:02.206)

    We’ve got this zeitgeist of people that hate, you know, you used an M-dash. How dare you? You know, that’s faking it. That’s cheating, you know. And you’ve got people on the other side saying, no, you will use AI to create content. And so ultimately I think we get over that hump. And it and and content just goes back to being good or bad. And, you know, whether or not, you know, we we we less not forget slop has always existed, right? It’s just that now AI is scaling it, right? We we’ve always had slop. It’s just now AI has more of it.

    John Jantsch (15:25.036)

    Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean what, two thousand four, five, six when people realized that blogging content got, you know, consumed and indexed by by Google, I think that’s when the slop started, right?

    Robert Rose (15:43.293)

    Ex well, that’s exactly right. I mean, you know, I mean, arguably we’ve had slop since the printing press, but you know, certainly, you know, we’ve we’ve we’ve we exponentially created more slop when Google started to say, hey, listen, by the way, if you can rank high for this page, you should. So we started, you know, I mean, how many horrible sloppy blog posts have have we written, read, consumed, whatever that basically were all keyword stuffed to the point where it just made no sense to the human? Well now

    The same thing is happening, but now it’s words like delve and you know, it’s not this, it’s that and you know, and and you know, and dashes.

    John Jantsch (16:11.928)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:17.119)

    my favorite is it seems like every time I ask for something written, it says most marketing agencies, you know, it’s like every single time. It starts with that line. So it’s it’s pretty popular and common to say, we got to keep a human in the loop. But let’s go back and like talk about how do you get quality. There are people that are get it using AI.

    Robert Rose (16:24.074)

    That’s right. That’s right. Or or or it or it’s a load bearing wall, right? It’s you know, it’s load bearing. Yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:46.114)

    have a process and are getting quality and certainly th there is, you know, there is a person probably that’s that’s helping with that. So if somebody came to you and said, well, we want to use AI and we only have a couple people, I mean, how would you advise them to to have that human component?

    Robert Rose (17:04.906)

    I think the key for me is independent of how it’s created, you ask yourself for every piece of content that you’re going to create, where is the human in this? In other words, where is the human that knows this statistic? Or where is the human that has this thought leadership claim or has this opinion and can back it up and will stand behind it? Who is the human customer who had this experience and is the part of this story?

    John Jantsch (17:15.617)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (17:33.567)

    Who where is your personal anecdote about the way it ha you know happened to you? And putting the human at the center of the story is something that AI just doesn’t do. It can help you, you know, craft an article around that, but it can’t put the human in the story. Only you can put the human in the story, which means slowing down, using AI for what it’s really good at, which is pressure testing your thinking, you know, maybe helping you come up with a clever way of saying something.

    But pressure testing thinking, doing, you know, aggregating research, looking for patterns, all those kinds of things, but making sure that you put you into the center of it, because then no matter what happens, you don’t regret the creation of the thing, right? You don’t recre, you know, you don’t regret the creation of the piece of content that you’re creating.

    John Jantsch (18:15.48)

    Yeah, yeah. So

    Increasingly, you know, it used to be we want to build our real estate, have all the stuff there, owned media was everything. increasingly getting cited, getting recommended is coming about because you got stuff other places, whether it was a podcast interview, it was research that somebody picked up and wrote about, it was a review. you know, so how do businesses, how do you think businesses need to manage that idea that we actually need to be

    maybe more places today if and getting sighted, you know, in in places that we maybe never even explored before. I’m I’ve got like small business owners asking me about Reddit, you know, that were like, wouldn’t have thought about it except they’re seeing all these Reddit sightings.

    Robert Rose (19:06.344)

    Yeah. It’s just remember that AI visibility is kind of a is is is too broad a way to look at it, but unfortunately it’s becoming sort of the du jour way of looking at it. Being mentioned and being cited are two very different content strategies. Being mentioned is just basically getting anything you can get out there to get out there. And being mentioned has very little value. Because remember, getting mentioned might be here’s all the solutions to not purchase, right? And so

    John Jantsch (19:33.336)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (19:34.485)

    Just being mentioned is not terribly productive. Being cited, however, being the source of an idea, being the source of something that AI quotes is a great thing. And to your point, that’s becoming, you know, more vocal in communities. It’s becoming covered more in industry journals. It’s becoming covered more on podcasts, on YouTube, on, you know, it’s getting your thought, your you, basically you, the human.

    out into the world more so that the AI finds you and cites you as an a source to an answer.

    John Jantsch (20:05.688)

    So i if you’re a leader of a business listening, what would what would your advice be for obviously you don’t know what they’re doing or where they are or the context, but what what’s typically your advice to a leader of a business of how they need to start thinking differently about AI use and and content today?

    Robert Rose (20:23.882)

    you know, I I start at the very foundational level and I say you need to understand your process first. In other words, understand what how you make marketing because many business owners I find when I ask them about marketing, they go, I don’t know. I got a kid and an agency that handles it and I don’t know how it works. I just I throw an idea in there and stuff comes out the other side. And so you have to understand that how the sausage gets made.

    John Jantsch (20:29.698)

    Yes.

    John Jantsch (20:37.57)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (20:48.776)

    And once you understand how the sausage gets made, you can start to identify places where AI may be able to help you do things either more efficiently, think more deeply, think more creatively, or actually, you know, increase the volume of what it is that you’re doing. But until you understand that, with no standard, there can be no improvement, as Akita Toyota used to say.

    John Jantsch (21:10.892)

    You you know, you mentioned the word process and we could probably do a whole nother show on this. I mean, in a lot of ways, would you suggest that that we actually need instead of looking at AI as a tool, is looking at it as part of the process. The process has to be defined, the outcome has to be defined before you ever plug a tool in.

    Robert Rose (21:28.34)

    Well, that that’s a great point. I mean, it’s yeah, it is a whole other show, which is the thing with AI is is that it’s gotten it’s gotten this rap as a technology and it’s not. It’s like a like it’s like, you know, when somebody says get good at AI, I say, just replace AI with electricity. You know, nobody’s telling you to go get good at electricity, right? It’s like, what does that mean, getting good at AI? What it means is is that you’re probably getting good at some other thing, right? Whether that’s content creation, marketing automation, measurement, you know.

    John Jantsch (21:30.416)

    Ha ha ha.

    John Jantsch (21:51.118)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (21:55.29)

    Optimization, A B testing, whatever the thing is, that’s where you’re applying AI as a as an overlay, as a and and that’s why understanding the process is such an important thing because it’s like it’s understanding the task that needs to get optimized, not the overall, you know, idea of, you know, the the body of water that encompasses it.

    John Jantsch (22:14.668)

    Yeah, yeah. Well, Robert, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. Is there any anywhere you’d invite people to connect with you and find out more about this research?

    Robert Rose (22:23.518)

    Yeah, please do. It’s LinkedIn is my best place. I’m a I’m a big LinkedIn user, so would love to connect with anybody on LinkedIn and and you know and have a chat about any of this. And of course my website is seventhbear.com.

    John Jantsch (22:36.162)

    Awesome. Well again, appreciate you taking a moment to stop by. Hopefully we’ll run it to you one of these days out there on the road.

    Robert Rose (22:41.95)

    Hundred percent. Yeah, absolutely. Great to see you.

    John Jantsch (22:44.419)

    You too. Take care, Rob.

  • How Much Cash Should Your Agency Keep in the Bank?

    How Much Cash Should Your Agency Keep in the Bank? written by Jordan E read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode: Overview This one’s back from the vault. Most agency owners can point to a healthy profit margin on paper and still panic about payroll by the third week of the month. John Jantsch sits down with virtual CFO Jody Grunden to unpack why that gap between profit and cash exists, and […]

    Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Robert Rose, founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute, about this year’s B2B content marketing research. The survey of more than eight hundred marketers confirms what a lot of teams already feel. AI made content faster and cheaper to produce, companies spent that speed on volume, and the people doing the work are stretched thinner than ever.

    Rose explains why AI output drifts toward the most probable answer, how that’s building what he calls a beige wall of content, and why leadership keeps missing the burnout on their dashboards. We also get into the quiet loss of entry-level roles, where all that grunt work actually lands, and why fifty-two percent of companies still have no AI disclosure policy.

    This one is for small business owners and marketing leaders trying to use AI for content without sanding their brand down to average. Rose shares a simple test for every piece you publish, the difference between getting mentioned and getting cited in AI answers, and why you have to understand your marketing process before you plug in any tool.

    Guest bio

    Robert Rose is the founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute. He has worked with more than five hundred brands in twenty-five countries, including Salesforce, SAP, and Adidas. Each year he writes CMI’s B2B content marketing research report, one of the most closely watched studies in the industry. Rose is also the coauthor of Killing Marketing with Joe Pulizzi.

    Key takeaways

    • AI delivered on speed and efficiency, and most companies spent the gain on more volume. Teams are busier, and the marketing isn’t getting better.
    • Leadership sees productivity gains while practitioners feel the burnout, and human training and headcount sit at the bottom of many 2027 budget lists.
    • AI content is the most probable answer to a prompt. Without someone who can recognize good work, output slides toward average over time.
    • When everyone publishes more of the same, the result is a beige wall that makes it harder for any brand to stand out.
    • Entry-level tasks that companies assumed AI would absorb are landing on mid-level and senior marketers instead.
    • Cutting the bottom rung of the career ladder removes the training ground where marketers develop taste. Intentional, even analog, mentoring may be the answer.
    • Agencies that price on value can use AI to deliver more for the same fee without racing to the bottom on price.
    • For every piece of content, ask where the human is: the person who knows the statistic, stands behind the claim, lived the customer story, or owns the anecdote.
    • Getting cited as a source in AI answers matters far more than getting mentioned, and citations come from podcasts, communities, industry press, and research.
    • Understand how your marketing gets made before adding AI. Treat it as an overlay on a defined process, the way you’d treat electricity.

    Great moments

    • [00:01] – Why AI made B2B content cheaper without making it better
    • [01:00] – Reuniting nearly ten years after Killing Marketing
    • [02:20] – The two biggest surprises in this year’s research
    • [04:24] – Business owners waiting for AI to replace their people
    • [05:10] – Why AI content is “most probable” and how that creates the beige wall
    • [07:04] – The disappearing bottom rung of the career ladder
    • [08:32] – Rose’s first job and the three-month reading assignment that taught him what good looks like
    • [09:29] – Teams as long-term investments and technology as day trading
    • [10:49] – Should agencies charge more for AI-assisted work?
    • [12:52] – Fifty-two percent of companies have no AI disclosure policy
    • [15:02] – Em dash backlash and why slop has always existed
    • [17:04] – The one question to ask about every piece of content
    • [19:06] – Getting mentioned vs. getting cited in AI answers
    • [20:23] – Why leaders need to understand their marketing process first
    • [21:28] – Replace “get good at AI” with “get good at electricity”

    Memorable quotes

    “A human team is an investment that grows in value over time the more you invest in it. Technology is day trading.” – Robert Rose

    “What AI content is, is the most probable. It is the most probable answer to your question or your prompt.” – Rose

    “We’ve always had slop. It’s just now AI has more of it.” – Rose

    “Only you can put the human in the story.” – Rose

    “Being mentioned and being cited are two very different content strategies.” – Rose

    John Jantsch (00:01.624)

    You know, because of AI, B2B marketers have built a content machine that runs faster than ever. But the newest research says that machine makes everything cheaper and nothing better. And the people operating it feel the strain while the people in charge of it can’t see it on their dashboard. The gap was confirmed across more than 800 marketers, and that’s what we’re going to talk about today, the results of that survey. Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch.

    My guest today is Robert Rose. He’s the founder of Seventh Bear and Chief Strategy Advisor to Content Marketing Institute. He’s worked with more than 500 brands across 25 countries, including Salesforce, SAP, and Adidas. And every year he writes CMI’s B2B Content Marketing Research Report. And this year, the numbers on AI speed and trust are why he’s on the show today. Plus, he’s a good guy. Hey, Robert.

    Robert Rose (00:56.331)

    How are you, my friend? It’s been far too long since we’ve been together.

    John Jantsch (01:00.302)

    Yeah, you know, I think, and you’re gonna be able to tell me when this was, that that the last time you were on my show is with with Joe, and you guys had written killing marketing or something.

    Robert Rose (01:12.948)

    killing marketing. Yeah. Yeah. Which would have been almost ten years now. That’s it was twenty sixteen or twenty seventeen. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (01:16.96)

    Okay, thanks.

    Well what a testament to us hanging around, huh?

    Robert Rose (01:23.035)

    Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And we have all the grey in our hair to prove it, so so

    John Jantsch (01:26.19)

    So I guess the I guess the first question is like, what did you get wrong in killing marketing? Like what what what is what has changed that made that like okay, if we’d have known that

    Robert Rose (01:38.496)

    Y well, I mean, you know, I mean, I know it’ll come up. It’s been maybe twenty five seconds since we’ve talked about AI, but but you know, of course, you know, we I don’t think I either of us were anticipating the disruption that AI would truly have on well, the world of business full stop. But certainly marketing has been the the focus with generative AI being at the center of that and you know, and how that is really affecting how we create valuable content, which of course is what killing marketing was all about.

    John Jantsch (02:07.544)

    So I I guess let’s just cut to the chase for those people that ha don’t have very long attention spans. what what what blew you away in this research this year? What’s like the one giant wow.

    Robert Rose (02:13.706)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (02:20.053)

    I you know, it was it was there was two giant wows, I think. one very positive and one you know, it it sounds like a negative at first, but I think it’s a big positive. And then the other, which is a negative that I think is a negative. And the first one is this idea that ostensibly AI has done what it meant to do or what the f you know, frontier models have all marketed us to do, which was we were promised in twenty two and twenty three.

    John Jantsch (02:24.27)

    Okay, okay.

    Robert Rose (02:46.527)

    That this was gonna remove the drudgery. We were gonna have all this time to do creative thinking and strategy and all this thing because AI was going to remove all that drudgery and it’s done the first part of that, right? It’s maked us faster and it’s made us more efficient. But what businesses have done with that speed and efficiency is just doubled up, doubled down on volume, right? And so we haven’t

    John Jantsch (03:06.496)

    Yeah. Yeah, I I talk to people all the time, they’re like, I’m working more than I ever was.

    Robert Rose (03:11.007)

    That’s exactly right. So we’re we’re creating double the amount of content now and you know and and and double the amount of effort. And then so that’s the the first sort of validating thing is is that it has not provided the quality or the you know the sort of value in making our marketing better, but it has made us busier as a result of it. And that’s sort of validating from a perspective of it feels that way, right? And you know, we the the gut feel is there. So it’s very validating. The second, which I think is probably the

    the the the negative one is the disparity between leadership and where the practitioners are in the business where senior leadership doesn’t see that right they’re they’re they’re seeing more productivity more efficiency and more speed and not seeing the burnout and not seeing the the you know the the the quality sort of slowly degrade and ultimately the last item on the twenty twenty seven budget list right now is human development, human skills training, human, you know, sort of headcount.

    And I think that’s a portend of of of very bad things to come if we don’t reinvest in human teams again.

    John Jantsch (04:17.602)

    Yeah, I mean you almost get the feeling from from some folks that they’re just waiting for AI to get good enough so they could get rid of their people.

    Robert Rose (04:24.105)

    Yeah, that’s right. That’s right. There I and and I’ve actually heard CMOs, I believe short sighted CMOs or even business owners in smaller and medium sized businesses say exactly that, right? You know, they’ve always seen marketing as kind of a tax. And so, you know, they’re just waiting for the robots to get good enough to replace the humans. And it’s like, boy, is that misguided.

    John Jantsch (04:44.248)

    You know, a year ago, we were probably still saying, like, how many people are using AI? you know, what’s the what’s the usage, you know, going on? And now it’s like everybody. you know, so that’s no longer a valid question, right? But what’s interesting, of course, you know, I I’m not sure I needed a survey to say this, but that that people are saying the quality, you know, still stinks. I mean, w why? You know, why does the quality stick?

    Robert Rose (05:10.719)

    I you know, I’ve been chalking it up to this. So look, we know there’s a lot of, you know, i in the early days, and even to some extent now, we get this sort of AI content is average, right? You know, we get this, you know, AI content is mediocre. And it’s like it’s not that’s technically not true. What AI content is is the most probable, right? It is the most probable answer to your question or your prompt. And most probable in some cases can be good. It can be clever, it can be really quite good.

    But it’s also what’s already existing, right? Because it has to be, because that’s what is most probable, is something that already exists in the world. And thus, if you don’t recognize what good looks like, in other words, if you as the human don’t understand that this is mediocre or this is fantastic, you end up averaging out over time. And so what’s happening is with that focus on speed and volume being the big thing.

    John Jantsch (05:43.885)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (05:54.263)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (06:05.385)

    Mo many businesses are just dumping more spaghetti against the wall and being surprised that less and less of it is actually sticking. And so it’s creating, I call it the beige wall, right? We’re we’re just creating this beige wall of content out there, which because everybody’s doing it, it means it’s even harder for us to get noticed, differentiated, and create distinctiveness in our own brand. Thus, what we’re really seeing is that degradation of quality content over time. And that’s just providing poorer.

    Poorer marketing efforts all the way around.

    John Jantsch (06:37.506)

    Yeah, but at least there’s more of it.

    Robert Rose (06:39.273)

    Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. It’s cheaper, right? You know, that’s the thing. It’s like if you look at it on a spreadsheet, it’s like, well, it’s cheaper to create. And it’s so that ROI is there because if it does anything, it’s actually making money. But it’s not actually making our marketing any better. It’s just making it cheaper and more commoditized.

    John Jantsch (06:56.894)

    Another statistic that that I think kind of jumped out at me is that people aren’t really pointing to efficiencies.

    Robert Rose (07:04.509)

    No. No. That’s that, you know, that’s that. Well, you know, cause that and that gets to your point where you were saying, you that you’re hearing a lot of like, well, we’ll just wait for the AI to get good enough to basically replace people. What’s happening is we can see this in so many businesses, small, medium, and large enterprises, people are cutting off the lower rung of the career ladder, right? So all of the young people, interns, inexperienced people, we are those are the ones that are getting assumed with the, you know, with the tasks.

    John Jantsch (07:24.344)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (07:32.159)

    You know, that AI will now take over and so they’re just not getting hired. But what the research showed us is that those tasks are not getting subsumed into AI. They’re actually just getting moved further up the career ladder. In other words, mid-level and senior level people are actually having to do all that work now. So they’re the ones that now get the email from the CEO saying, I know you’re busy. So I just had Claude whip up a white paper. Can you just do your magic on it and edit it for me? Right. So they’re busier than ever, doing more grunt work than ever.

    John Jantsch (07:45.486)

    Sure.

    John Jantsch (07:59.501)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (08:01.256)

    And it’s basically just because we don’t have the people or the skills or the you know the the the head count and the to be able to do it.

    John Jantsch (08:09.442)

    Yeah, and of course there’s a lot of a growing number of people. I’m not sure, you know, this this this involves investing in your people intentionally. And so I’m not sure it’s high on some people’s list. But there’s growing concern that, you know, you and I learned how to have taste and how to actually know what is good and what is bad by doing the groundwork. And and that’s like, where’s that training ground?

    Robert Rose (08:32.297)

    Hundred percent.

    Yeah, that’s exactly right. My first job, you know, and I tell this story in the research report. My first job was for a television network. And my first day on the job, my boss walked into me with a stack of industry magazines and basically said, Your first job is to read every single one of these and start to understand our industry jargon, to understand what we do for a living, and basically gave me a job of of of internally auditing all the things in the TV network. And it took me three months. It would take AI 16 minutes to do that same task.

    John Jantsch (09:03.842)

    Mm-hmm.

    Robert Rose (09:05.268)

    But what it did was it gave me a foundational education on what good actually looked like in the business and helped me be a better employee. And we’re just losing that we’re losing that developmental skill.

    John Jantsch (09:16.748)

    Yeah. So so I mean, does a company have to actually say, Okay, I know it’s very inefficient to make you read this stuff, but you have to? I mean, is it is that what it’s gonna take? Like a mentoring program that’s like analog? Yeah.

    Robert Rose (09:29.716)

    Yeah, I really do. I I believe in this. I believe that, you know, so look, my belief, and you know, maybe this is me being a little, you know, tilting at windmills or whatever, but but I I think my belief is is that a team, a human team, is an investment that grows in value over time the more you invest in it. Technology is day trading. Technology is whatever you did yesterday is only as good as what you put into it today. And so that transactional effort doesn’t actually

    Increase in value over time. In fact, it decreases in value over time. But your team, as it as it gets wisdom, as it gets experience, as it gets the ability to, you know, realize what discernment, you’re not only building the second layer of upper management that is invested in your business, you’re also building in wisdom and discernment into the marketing team itself so the team becomes better and it can transfer that knowledge to the new people who come in and so on and so forth. So it’s in,

    It’s an asset. The marketing team to me is an asset worth investing in. And technology is simply a tool that basically, you know, makes it makes it more efficient. And so investing in the latter is just literally triaging, you know, the day and trying to get, you know, some incremental increase in investment in a very short period of time, where the long term investment is people.

    John Jantsch (10:49.208)

    So I don’t think your research actually went into this idea, but you know, I have l contended, at least in my own business, that while we’re using AI and in and maybe, you know, it’s causing people to do more, if nothing else, causing them to learn how to use the AI tool, you know, as as part of their job. But I wanna I wanna contend that we are delivering more value to our clients for the same commitment, the same dollar amount.

    we are delivering more value. and I don’t know if we are looking at it that correctly, like should we be charging more? or, you know, is the client just benefiting from the fact that we know how to use this tool on their behalf?

    Robert Rose (11:31.627)

    I think the latter is the way I come down on it, which is I don’t buy into the zeitgeist of agencies are irrelevant anymore, certainly. And I don’t buy into the zeitgeist of that we should be charging less because we have AI tools to help us do our jobs, right? To make us more efficient. Because I’ve never believed in charging by the hour anyway, right? And so if we’re charging for value created, whether that’s, you know, there’s so many different models we could talk about in terms of the way that services are delivered, but if we’re chart, you know, if we’re basically saying,

    John Jantsch (11:49.518)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (12:01.298)

    It doesn’t matter how fast it takes us, what you’re what you’re what you’re, you know, what you’re being charged for, build for for us is the experience and the deliverable and the expertise and the quality of the thing that we’re delivering to you, no matter how fast or efficient we are at creating it. Then what you’re saying is basically we should be charging the same or more based on our ability to use the tool and an ability to create better work. And so that’s where I come down on this is that it is it is not about.

    you know, our AI forward, if you will, you know, sort of stance is not we’re more efficient, therefore we’re cheaper than the competition. It is that, yeah, sure, we use the tools, we use Photoshop, we use typewriters, we use computers, we use Xerox machines, we use electricity and lights and water, and we use all these technologies to make us better.

    John Jantsch (12:37.27)

    Is this?

    John Jantsch (12:48.491)

    a fax machine, throw that there, why not?

    Robert Rose (12:50.258)

    Yeah, the fax machine too. Yes, exactly.

    John Jantsch (12:52.43)

    I had the IRS wanted something from me, and the only way I could give it to them was to fax it to them. Can you believe that? Yeah. And unfortunately, it was a 200-page document, so have fun with that. That’s what you asked for. That’s what you got. So well, let’s go another direction. this doesn’t surprise me. In fact, I I find this shockingly low. 52% of companies have no disclosure policy, no governance, no

    Robert Rose (12:57.566)

    Yeah, I yes. It’s sadly it’s sad but true, yeah.

    Robert Rose (13:05.114)

    Yeah.

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (13:22.03)

    compliance, no whatever, on the legal side of it. In fact, most of the companies we end up working with, it’s pretty much bring your own device. yeah bring your own chat GPT account, you know, and go for it. I mean, are we in for a reckoning at some point on that, you think, or will this all settle down?

    Robert Rose (13:39.465)

    I think, well, you know, the interesting thing is, I think, you know, I’m not sure when this is gonna air, but the but over the last two weeks w I think we’ve seen the beginning of the reckoning of how some of that AI is being used, you know, with the FAA’s outage and and certainly with, you know, Microsoft’s outage and certainly with a lot of the outages that we’ve seen here, I think we’re going to come to find out. This is this is a prediction, I guess, or a hot take, if you will.

    John Jantsch (13:48.172)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (14:03.22)

    But I think we’re going to come to find out that a lot of this is sort of shortcuts in the way that we use AI to code and create patches for software and the sort of firing of engineering and all that sort of thing. That chicken is coming home to roost. similar things are happening in marketing as well. you know, and so and and the key there is is that disclosure policy, I think, and internal guidelines and standards are two different things, right? And so internal guidelines and standards are.

    John Jantsch (14:16.866)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (14:28.706)

    Mm-hmm.

    Robert Rose (14:32.73)

    100% needed and so low on most businesses’ priority lists because to your point, it’s bring your own device and figure it out, right? You know, bring your own chat GPT and figure it out. You know, I’ll use Gemini, they’ll use Chat GPT, they’re gonna use this, whatever, and never the twain shall meet. And so I think that changes over time and starts to get more governed, you know, and more governance and and and workflow to it. the disclosure policy, I think ultimately right now we’re in a weird place, right? Where

    John Jantsch (14:41.55)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (14:54.646)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (15:02.206)

    We’ve got this zeitgeist of people that hate, you know, you used an M-dash. How dare you? You know, that’s faking it. That’s cheating, you know. And you’ve got people on the other side saying, no, you will use AI to create content. And so ultimately I think we get over that hump. And it and and content just goes back to being good or bad. And, you know, whether or not, you know, we we we less not forget slop has always existed, right? It’s just that now AI is scaling it, right? We we’ve always had slop. It’s just now AI has more of it.

    John Jantsch (15:25.036)

    Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean what, two thousand four, five, six when people realized that blogging content got, you know, consumed and indexed by by Google, I think that’s when the slop started, right?

    Robert Rose (15:43.293)

    Ex well, that’s exactly right. I mean, you know, I mean, arguably we’ve had slop since the printing press, but you know, certainly, you know, we’ve we’ve we’ve we exponentially created more slop when Google started to say, hey, listen, by the way, if you can rank high for this page, you should. So we started, you know, I mean, how many horrible sloppy blog posts have have we written, read, consumed, whatever that basically were all keyword stuffed to the point where it just made no sense to the human? Well now

    The same thing is happening, but now it’s words like delve and you know, it’s not this, it’s that and you know, and and you know, and dashes.

    John Jantsch (16:11.928)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:17.119)

    my favorite is it seems like every time I ask for something written, it says most marketing agencies, you know, it’s like every single time. It starts with that line. So it’s it’s pretty popular and common to say, we got to keep a human in the loop. But let’s go back and like talk about how do you get quality. There are people that are get it using AI.

    Robert Rose (16:24.074)

    That’s right. That’s right. Or or or it or it’s a load bearing wall, right? It’s you know, it’s load bearing. Yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:46.114)

    have a process and are getting quality and certainly th there is, you know, there is a person probably that’s that’s helping with that. So if somebody came to you and said, well, we want to use AI and we only have a couple people, I mean, how would you advise them to to have that human component?

    Robert Rose (17:04.906)

    I think the key for me is independent of how it’s created, you ask yourself for every piece of content that you’re going to create, where is the human in this? In other words, where is the human that knows this statistic? Or where is the human that has this thought leadership claim or has this opinion and can back it up and will stand behind it? Who is the human customer who had this experience and is the part of this story?

    John Jantsch (17:15.617)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (17:33.567)

    Who where is your personal anecdote about the way it ha you know happened to you? And putting the human at the center of the story is something that AI just doesn’t do. It can help you, you know, craft an article around that, but it can’t put the human in the story. Only you can put the human in the story, which means slowing down, using AI for what it’s really good at, which is pressure testing your thinking, you know, maybe helping you come up with a clever way of saying something.

    But pressure testing thinking, doing, you know, aggregating research, looking for patterns, all those kinds of things, but making sure that you put you into the center of it, because then no matter what happens, you don’t regret the creation of the thing, right? You don’t recre, you know, you don’t regret the creation of the piece of content that you’re creating.

    John Jantsch (18:15.48)

    Yeah, yeah. So

    Increasingly, you know, it used to be we want to build our real estate, have all the stuff there, owned media was everything. increasingly getting cited, getting recommended is coming about because you got stuff other places, whether it was a podcast interview, it was research that somebody picked up and wrote about, it was a review. you know, so how do businesses, how do you think businesses need to manage that idea that we actually need to be

    maybe more places today if and getting sighted, you know, in in places that we maybe never even explored before. I’m I’ve got like small business owners asking me about Reddit, you know, that were like, wouldn’t have thought about it except they’re seeing all these Reddit sightings.

    Robert Rose (19:06.344)

    Yeah. It’s just remember that AI visibility is kind of a is is is too broad a way to look at it, but unfortunately it’s becoming sort of the du jour way of looking at it. Being mentioned and being cited are two very different content strategies. Being mentioned is just basically getting anything you can get out there to get out there. And being mentioned has very little value. Because remember, getting mentioned might be here’s all the solutions to not purchase, right? And so

    John Jantsch (19:33.336)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (19:34.485)

    Just being mentioned is not terribly productive. Being cited, however, being the source of an idea, being the source of something that AI quotes is a great thing. And to your point, that’s becoming, you know, more vocal in communities. It’s becoming covered more in industry journals. It’s becoming covered more on podcasts, on YouTube, on, you know, it’s getting your thought, your you, basically you, the human.

    out into the world more so that the AI finds you and cites you as an a source to an answer.

    John Jantsch (20:05.688)

    So i if you’re a leader of a business listening, what would what would your advice be for obviously you don’t know what they’re doing or where they are or the context, but what what’s typically your advice to a leader of a business of how they need to start thinking differently about AI use and and content today?

    Robert Rose (20:23.882)

    you know, I I start at the very foundational level and I say you need to understand your process first. In other words, understand what how you make marketing because many business owners I find when I ask them about marketing, they go, I don’t know. I got a kid and an agency that handles it and I don’t know how it works. I just I throw an idea in there and stuff comes out the other side. And so you have to understand that how the sausage gets made.

    John Jantsch (20:29.698)

    Yes.

    John Jantsch (20:37.57)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (20:48.776)

    And once you understand how the sausage gets made, you can start to identify places where AI may be able to help you do things either more efficiently, think more deeply, think more creatively, or actually, you know, increase the volume of what it is that you’re doing. But until you understand that, with no standard, there can be no improvement, as Akita Toyota used to say.

    John Jantsch (21:10.892)

    You you know, you mentioned the word process and we could probably do a whole nother show on this. I mean, in a lot of ways, would you suggest that that we actually need instead of looking at AI as a tool, is looking at it as part of the process. The process has to be defined, the outcome has to be defined before you ever plug a tool in.

    Robert Rose (21:28.34)

    Well, that that’s a great point. I mean, it’s yeah, it is a whole other show, which is the thing with AI is is that it’s gotten it’s gotten this rap as a technology and it’s not. It’s like a like it’s like, you know, when somebody says get good at AI, I say, just replace AI with electricity. You know, nobody’s telling you to go get good at electricity, right? It’s like, what does that mean, getting good at AI? What it means is is that you’re probably getting good at some other thing, right? Whether that’s content creation, marketing automation, measurement, you know.

    John Jantsch (21:30.416)

    Ha ha ha.

    John Jantsch (21:51.118)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (21:55.29)

    Optimization, A B testing, whatever the thing is, that’s where you’re applying AI as a as an overlay, as a and and that’s why understanding the process is such an important thing because it’s like it’s understanding the task that needs to get optimized, not the overall, you know, idea of, you know, the the body of water that encompasses it.

    John Jantsch (22:14.668)

    Yeah, yeah. Well, Robert, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. Is there any anywhere you’d invite people to connect with you and find out more about this research?

    Robert Rose (22:23.518)

    Yeah, please do. It’s LinkedIn is my best place. I’m a I’m a big LinkedIn user, so would love to connect with anybody on LinkedIn and and you know and have a chat about any of this. And of course my website is seventhbear.com.

    John Jantsch (22:36.162)

    Awesome. Well again, appreciate you taking a moment to stop by. Hopefully we’ll run it to you one of these days out there on the road.

    Robert Rose (22:41.95)

    Hundred percent. Yeah, absolutely. Great to see you.

    John Jantsch (22:44.419)

    You too. Take care, Rob.

  • Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better

    Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode: Overview On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Robert Rose, founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute, about this year’s B2B content marketing research. The survey of more than eight hundred marketers confirms what a lot of teams already feel. AI […]

    Why AI Is Making Content Marketing Faster, Not Better written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Robert Rose, founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute, about this year’s B2B content marketing research. The survey of more than eight hundred marketers confirms what a lot of teams already feel. AI made content faster and cheaper to produce, companies spent that speed on volume, and the people doing the work are stretched thinner than ever.

    Rose explains why AI output drifts toward the most probable answer, how that’s building what he calls a beige wall of content, and why leadership keeps missing the burnout on their dashboards. We also get into the quiet loss of entry-level roles, where all that grunt work actually lands, and why fifty-two percent of companies still have no AI disclosure policy.

    This one is for small business owners and marketing leaders trying to use AI for content without sanding their brand down to average. Rose shares a simple test for every piece you publish, the difference between getting mentioned and getting cited in AI answers, and why you have to understand your marketing process before you plug in any tool.

    Guest bio

    Robert Rose is the founder of Seventh Bear and chief strategy advisor to Content Marketing Institute. He has worked with more than five hundred brands in twenty-five countries, including Salesforce, SAP, and Adidas. Each year he writes CMI’s B2B content marketing research report, one of the most closely watched studies in the industry. Rose is also the coauthor of Killing Marketing with Joe Pulizzi.

    Key takeaways

    • AI delivered on speed and efficiency, and most companies spent the gain on more volume. Teams are busier, and the marketing isn’t getting better.
    • Leadership sees productivity gains while practitioners feel the burnout, and human training and headcount sit at the bottom of many 2027 budget lists.
    • AI content is the most probable answer to a prompt. Without someone who can recognize good work, output slides toward average over time.
    • When everyone publishes more of the same, the result is a beige wall that makes it harder for any brand to stand out.
    • Entry-level tasks that companies assumed AI would absorb are landing on mid-level and senior marketers instead.
    • Cutting the bottom rung of the career ladder removes the training ground where marketers develop taste. Intentional, even analog, mentoring may be the answer.
    • Agencies that price on value can use AI to deliver more for the same fee without racing to the bottom on price.
    • For every piece of content, ask where the human is: the person who knows the statistic, stands behind the claim, lived the customer story, or owns the anecdote.
    • Getting cited as a source in AI answers matters far more than getting mentioned, and citations come from podcasts, communities, industry press, and research.
    • Understand how your marketing gets made before adding AI. Treat it as an overlay on a defined process, the way you’d treat electricity.

    Great moments

    • [00:01] – Why AI made B2B content cheaper without making it better
    • [01:00] – Reuniting nearly ten years after Killing Marketing
    • [02:20] – The two biggest surprises in this year’s research
    • [04:24] – Business owners waiting for AI to replace their people
    • [05:10] – Why AI content is “most probable” and how that creates the beige wall
    • [07:04] – The disappearing bottom rung of the career ladder
    • [08:32] – Rose’s first job and the three-month reading assignment that taught him what good looks like
    • [09:29] – Teams as long-term investments and technology as day trading
    • [10:49] – Should agencies charge more for AI-assisted work?
    • [12:52] – Fifty-two percent of companies have no AI disclosure policy
    • [15:02] – Em dash backlash and why slop has always existed
    • [17:04] – The one question to ask about every piece of content
    • [19:06] – Getting mentioned vs. getting cited in AI answers
    • [20:23] – Why leaders need to understand their marketing process first
    • [21:28] – Replace “get good at AI” with “get good at electricity”

    Memorable quotes

    “A human team is an investment that grows in value over time the more you invest in it. Technology is day trading.” – Robert Rose

    “What AI content is, is the most probable. It is the most probable answer to your question or your prompt.” – Rose

    “We’ve always had slop. It’s just now AI has more of it.” – Rose

    “Only you can put the human in the story.” – Rose

    “Being mentioned and being cited are two very different content strategies.” – Rose

    John Jantsch (00:01.624)

    You know, because of AI, B2B marketers have built a content machine that runs faster than ever. But the newest research says that machine makes everything cheaper and nothing better. And the people operating it feel the strain while the people in charge of it can’t see it on their dashboard. The gap was confirmed across more than 800 marketers, and that’s what we’re going to talk about today, the results of that survey. Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch.

    My guest today is Robert Rose. He’s the founder of Seventh Bear and Chief Strategy Advisor to Content Marketing Institute. He’s worked with more than 500 brands across 25 countries, including Salesforce, SAP, and Adidas. And every year he writes CMI’s B2B Content Marketing Research Report. And this year, the numbers on AI speed and trust are why he’s on the show today. Plus, he’s a good guy. Hey, Robert.

    Robert Rose (00:56.331)

    How are you, my friend? It’s been far too long since we’ve been together.

    John Jantsch (01:00.302)

    Yeah, you know, I think, and you’re gonna be able to tell me when this was, that that the last time you were on my show is with with Joe, and you guys had written killing marketing or something.

    Robert Rose (01:12.948)

    killing marketing. Yeah. Yeah. Which would have been almost ten years now. That’s it was twenty sixteen or twenty seventeen. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (01:16.96)

    Okay, thanks.

    Well what a testament to us hanging around, huh?

    Robert Rose (01:23.035)

    Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And we have all the grey in our hair to prove it, so so

    John Jantsch (01:26.19)

    So I guess the I guess the first question is like, what did you get wrong in killing marketing? Like what what what is what has changed that made that like okay, if we’d have known that

    Robert Rose (01:38.496)

    Y well, I mean, you know, I mean, I know it’ll come up. It’s been maybe twenty five seconds since we’ve talked about AI, but but you know, of course, you know, we I don’t think I either of us were anticipating the disruption that AI would truly have on well, the world of business full stop. But certainly marketing has been the the focus with generative AI being at the center of that and you know, and how that is really affecting how we create valuable content, which of course is what killing marketing was all about.

    John Jantsch (02:07.544)

    So I I guess let’s just cut to the chase for those people that ha don’t have very long attention spans. what what what blew you away in this research this year? What’s like the one giant wow.

    Robert Rose (02:13.706)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (02:20.053)

    I you know, it was it was there was two giant wows, I think. one very positive and one you know, it it sounds like a negative at first, but I think it’s a big positive. And then the other, which is a negative that I think is a negative. And the first one is this idea that ostensibly AI has done what it meant to do or what the f you know, frontier models have all marketed us to do, which was we were promised in twenty two and twenty three.

    John Jantsch (02:24.27)

    Okay, okay.

    Robert Rose (02:46.527)

    That this was gonna remove the drudgery. We were gonna have all this time to do creative thinking and strategy and all this thing because AI was going to remove all that drudgery and it’s done the first part of that, right? It’s maked us faster and it’s made us more efficient. But what businesses have done with that speed and efficiency is just doubled up, doubled down on volume, right? And so we haven’t

    John Jantsch (03:06.496)

    Yeah. Yeah, I I talk to people all the time, they’re like, I’m working more than I ever was.

    Robert Rose (03:11.007)

    That’s exactly right. So we’re we’re creating double the amount of content now and you know and and and double the amount of effort. And then so that’s the the first sort of validating thing is is that it has not provided the quality or the you know the sort of value in making our marketing better, but it has made us busier as a result of it. And that’s sort of validating from a perspective of it feels that way, right? And you know, we the the gut feel is there. So it’s very validating. The second, which I think is probably the

    the the the negative one is the disparity between leadership and where the practitioners are in the business where senior leadership doesn’t see that right they’re they’re they’re seeing more productivity more efficiency and more speed and not seeing the burnout and not seeing the the you know the the the quality sort of slowly degrade and ultimately the last item on the twenty twenty seven budget list right now is human development, human skills training, human, you know, sort of headcount.

    And I think that’s a portend of of of very bad things to come if we don’t reinvest in human teams again.

    John Jantsch (04:17.602)

    Yeah, I mean you almost get the feeling from from some folks that they’re just waiting for AI to get good enough so they could get rid of their people.

    Robert Rose (04:24.105)

    Yeah, that’s right. That’s right. There I and and I’ve actually heard CMOs, I believe short sighted CMOs or even business owners in smaller and medium sized businesses say exactly that, right? You know, they’ve always seen marketing as kind of a tax. And so, you know, they’re just waiting for the robots to get good enough to replace the humans. And it’s like, boy, is that misguided.

    John Jantsch (04:44.248)

    You know, a year ago, we were probably still saying, like, how many people are using AI? you know, what’s the what’s the usage, you know, going on? And now it’s like everybody. you know, so that’s no longer a valid question, right? But what’s interesting, of course, you know, I I’m not sure I needed a survey to say this, but that that people are saying the quality, you know, still stinks. I mean, w why? You know, why does the quality stick?

    Robert Rose (05:10.719)

    I you know, I’ve been chalking it up to this. So look, we know there’s a lot of, you know, i in the early days, and even to some extent now, we get this sort of AI content is average, right? You know, we get this, you know, AI content is mediocre. And it’s like it’s not that’s technically not true. What AI content is is the most probable, right? It is the most probable answer to your question or your prompt. And most probable in some cases can be good. It can be clever, it can be really quite good.

    But it’s also what’s already existing, right? Because it has to be, because that’s what is most probable, is something that already exists in the world. And thus, if you don’t recognize what good looks like, in other words, if you as the human don’t understand that this is mediocre or this is fantastic, you end up averaging out over time. And so what’s happening is with that focus on speed and volume being the big thing.

    John Jantsch (05:43.885)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (05:54.263)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (06:05.385)

    Mo many businesses are just dumping more spaghetti against the wall and being surprised that less and less of it is actually sticking. And so it’s creating, I call it the beige wall, right? We’re we’re just creating this beige wall of content out there, which because everybody’s doing it, it means it’s even harder for us to get noticed, differentiated, and create distinctiveness in our own brand. Thus, what we’re really seeing is that degradation of quality content over time. And that’s just providing poorer.

    Poorer marketing efforts all the way around.

    John Jantsch (06:37.506)

    Yeah, but at least there’s more of it.

    Robert Rose (06:39.273)

    Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Yeah. It’s cheaper, right? You know, that’s the thing. It’s like if you look at it on a spreadsheet, it’s like, well, it’s cheaper to create. And it’s so that ROI is there because if it does anything, it’s actually making money. But it’s not actually making our marketing any better. It’s just making it cheaper and more commoditized.

    John Jantsch (06:56.894)

    Another statistic that that I think kind of jumped out at me is that people aren’t really pointing to efficiencies.

    Robert Rose (07:04.509)

    No. No. That’s that, you know, that’s that. Well, you know, cause that and that gets to your point where you were saying, you that you’re hearing a lot of like, well, we’ll just wait for the AI to get good enough to basically replace people. What’s happening is we can see this in so many businesses, small, medium, and large enterprises, people are cutting off the lower rung of the career ladder, right? So all of the young people, interns, inexperienced people, we are those are the ones that are getting assumed with the, you know, with the tasks.

    John Jantsch (07:24.344)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (07:32.159)

    You know, that AI will now take over and so they’re just not getting hired. But what the research showed us is that those tasks are not getting subsumed into AI. They’re actually just getting moved further up the career ladder. In other words, mid-level and senior level people are actually having to do all that work now. So they’re the ones that now get the email from the CEO saying, I know you’re busy. So I just had Claude whip up a white paper. Can you just do your magic on it and edit it for me? Right. So they’re busier than ever, doing more grunt work than ever.

    John Jantsch (07:45.486)

    Sure.

    John Jantsch (07:59.501)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (08:01.256)

    And it’s basically just because we don’t have the people or the skills or the you know the the the head count and the to be able to do it.

    John Jantsch (08:09.442)

    Yeah, and of course there’s a lot of a growing number of people. I’m not sure, you know, this this this involves investing in your people intentionally. And so I’m not sure it’s high on some people’s list. But there’s growing concern that, you know, you and I learned how to have taste and how to actually know what is good and what is bad by doing the groundwork. And and that’s like, where’s that training ground?

    Robert Rose (08:32.297)

    Hundred percent.

    Yeah, that’s exactly right. My first job, you know, and I tell this story in the research report. My first job was for a television network. And my first day on the job, my boss walked into me with a stack of industry magazines and basically said, Your first job is to read every single one of these and start to understand our industry jargon, to understand what we do for a living, and basically gave me a job of of of internally auditing all the things in the TV network. And it took me three months. It would take AI 16 minutes to do that same task.

    John Jantsch (09:03.842)

    Mm-hmm.

    Robert Rose (09:05.268)

    But what it did was it gave me a foundational education on what good actually looked like in the business and helped me be a better employee. And we’re just losing that we’re losing that developmental skill.

    John Jantsch (09:16.748)

    Yeah. So so I mean, does a company have to actually say, Okay, I know it’s very inefficient to make you read this stuff, but you have to? I mean, is it is that what it’s gonna take? Like a mentoring program that’s like analog? Yeah.

    Robert Rose (09:29.716)

    Yeah, I really do. I I believe in this. I believe that, you know, so look, my belief, and you know, maybe this is me being a little, you know, tilting at windmills or whatever, but but I I think my belief is is that a team, a human team, is an investment that grows in value over time the more you invest in it. Technology is day trading. Technology is whatever you did yesterday is only as good as what you put into it today. And so that transactional effort doesn’t actually

    Increase in value over time. In fact, it decreases in value over time. But your team, as it as it gets wisdom, as it gets experience, as it gets the ability to, you know, realize what discernment, you’re not only building the second layer of upper management that is invested in your business, you’re also building in wisdom and discernment into the marketing team itself so the team becomes better and it can transfer that knowledge to the new people who come in and so on and so forth. So it’s in,

    It’s an asset. The marketing team to me is an asset worth investing in. And technology is simply a tool that basically, you know, makes it makes it more efficient. And so investing in the latter is just literally triaging, you know, the day and trying to get, you know, some incremental increase in investment in a very short period of time, where the long term investment is people.

    John Jantsch (10:49.208)

    So I don’t think your research actually went into this idea, but you know, I have l contended, at least in my own business, that while we’re using AI and in and maybe, you know, it’s causing people to do more, if nothing else, causing them to learn how to use the AI tool, you know, as as part of their job. But I wanna I wanna contend that we are delivering more value to our clients for the same commitment, the same dollar amount.

    we are delivering more value. and I don’t know if we are looking at it that correctly, like should we be charging more? or, you know, is the client just benefiting from the fact that we know how to use this tool on their behalf?

    Robert Rose (11:31.627)

    I think the latter is the way I come down on it, which is I don’t buy into the zeitgeist of agencies are irrelevant anymore, certainly. And I don’t buy into the zeitgeist of that we should be charging less because we have AI tools to help us do our jobs, right? To make us more efficient. Because I’ve never believed in charging by the hour anyway, right? And so if we’re charging for value created, whether that’s, you know, there’s so many different models we could talk about in terms of the way that services are delivered, but if we’re chart, you know, if we’re basically saying,

    John Jantsch (11:49.518)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (12:01.298)

    It doesn’t matter how fast it takes us, what you’re what you’re what you’re, you know, what you’re being charged for, build for for us is the experience and the deliverable and the expertise and the quality of the thing that we’re delivering to you, no matter how fast or efficient we are at creating it. Then what you’re saying is basically we should be charging the same or more based on our ability to use the tool and an ability to create better work. And so that’s where I come down on this is that it is it is not about.

    you know, our AI forward, if you will, you know, sort of stance is not we’re more efficient, therefore we’re cheaper than the competition. It is that, yeah, sure, we use the tools, we use Photoshop, we use typewriters, we use computers, we use Xerox machines, we use electricity and lights and water, and we use all these technologies to make us better.

    John Jantsch (12:37.27)

    Is this?

    John Jantsch (12:48.491)

    a fax machine, throw that there, why not?

    Robert Rose (12:50.258)

    Yeah, the fax machine too. Yes, exactly.

    John Jantsch (12:52.43)

    I had the IRS wanted something from me, and the only way I could give it to them was to fax it to them. Can you believe that? Yeah. And unfortunately, it was a 200-page document, so have fun with that. That’s what you asked for. That’s what you got. So well, let’s go another direction. this doesn’t surprise me. In fact, I I find this shockingly low. 52% of companies have no disclosure policy, no governance, no

    Robert Rose (12:57.566)

    Yeah, I yes. It’s sadly it’s sad but true, yeah.

    Robert Rose (13:05.114)

    Yeah.

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (13:22.03)

    compliance, no whatever, on the legal side of it. In fact, most of the companies we end up working with, it’s pretty much bring your own device. yeah bring your own chat GPT account, you know, and go for it. I mean, are we in for a reckoning at some point on that, you think, or will this all settle down?

    Robert Rose (13:39.465)

    I think, well, you know, the interesting thing is, I think, you know, I’m not sure when this is gonna air, but the but over the last two weeks w I think we’ve seen the beginning of the reckoning of how some of that AI is being used, you know, with the FAA’s outage and and certainly with, you know, Microsoft’s outage and certainly with a lot of the outages that we’ve seen here, I think we’re going to come to find out. This is this is a prediction, I guess, or a hot take, if you will.

    John Jantsch (13:48.172)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (14:03.22)

    But I think we’re going to come to find out that a lot of this is sort of shortcuts in the way that we use AI to code and create patches for software and the sort of firing of engineering and all that sort of thing. That chicken is coming home to roost. similar things are happening in marketing as well. you know, and so and and the key there is is that disclosure policy, I think, and internal guidelines and standards are two different things, right? And so internal guidelines and standards are.

    John Jantsch (14:16.866)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (14:28.706)

    Mm-hmm.

    Robert Rose (14:32.73)

    100% needed and so low on most businesses’ priority lists because to your point, it’s bring your own device and figure it out, right? You know, bring your own chat GPT and figure it out. You know, I’ll use Gemini, they’ll use Chat GPT, they’re gonna use this, whatever, and never the twain shall meet. And so I think that changes over time and starts to get more governed, you know, and more governance and and and workflow to it. the disclosure policy, I think ultimately right now we’re in a weird place, right? Where

    John Jantsch (14:41.55)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (14:54.646)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (15:02.206)

    We’ve got this zeitgeist of people that hate, you know, you used an M-dash. How dare you? You know, that’s faking it. That’s cheating, you know. And you’ve got people on the other side saying, no, you will use AI to create content. And so ultimately I think we get over that hump. And it and and content just goes back to being good or bad. And, you know, whether or not, you know, we we we less not forget slop has always existed, right? It’s just that now AI is scaling it, right? We we’ve always had slop. It’s just now AI has more of it.

    John Jantsch (15:25.036)

    Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean what, two thousand four, five, six when people realized that blogging content got, you know, consumed and indexed by by Google, I think that’s when the slop started, right?

    Robert Rose (15:43.293)

    Ex well, that’s exactly right. I mean, you know, I mean, arguably we’ve had slop since the printing press, but you know, certainly, you know, we’ve we’ve we’ve we exponentially created more slop when Google started to say, hey, listen, by the way, if you can rank high for this page, you should. So we started, you know, I mean, how many horrible sloppy blog posts have have we written, read, consumed, whatever that basically were all keyword stuffed to the point where it just made no sense to the human? Well now

    The same thing is happening, but now it’s words like delve and you know, it’s not this, it’s that and you know, and and you know, and dashes.

    John Jantsch (16:11.928)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:17.119)

    my favorite is it seems like every time I ask for something written, it says most marketing agencies, you know, it’s like every single time. It starts with that line. So it’s it’s pretty popular and common to say, we got to keep a human in the loop. But let’s go back and like talk about how do you get quality. There are people that are get it using AI.

    Robert Rose (16:24.074)

    That’s right. That’s right. Or or or it or it’s a load bearing wall, right? It’s you know, it’s load bearing. Yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:46.114)

    have a process and are getting quality and certainly th there is, you know, there is a person probably that’s that’s helping with that. So if somebody came to you and said, well, we want to use AI and we only have a couple people, I mean, how would you advise them to to have that human component?

    Robert Rose (17:04.906)

    I think the key for me is independent of how it’s created, you ask yourself for every piece of content that you’re going to create, where is the human in this? In other words, where is the human that knows this statistic? Or where is the human that has this thought leadership claim or has this opinion and can back it up and will stand behind it? Who is the human customer who had this experience and is the part of this story?

    John Jantsch (17:15.617)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (17:33.567)

    Who where is your personal anecdote about the way it ha you know happened to you? And putting the human at the center of the story is something that AI just doesn’t do. It can help you, you know, craft an article around that, but it can’t put the human in the story. Only you can put the human in the story, which means slowing down, using AI for what it’s really good at, which is pressure testing your thinking, you know, maybe helping you come up with a clever way of saying something.

    But pressure testing thinking, doing, you know, aggregating research, looking for patterns, all those kinds of things, but making sure that you put you into the center of it, because then no matter what happens, you don’t regret the creation of the thing, right? You don’t recre, you know, you don’t regret the creation of the piece of content that you’re creating.

    John Jantsch (18:15.48)

    Yeah, yeah. So

    Increasingly, you know, it used to be we want to build our real estate, have all the stuff there, owned media was everything. increasingly getting cited, getting recommended is coming about because you got stuff other places, whether it was a podcast interview, it was research that somebody picked up and wrote about, it was a review. you know, so how do businesses, how do you think businesses need to manage that idea that we actually need to be

    maybe more places today if and getting sighted, you know, in in places that we maybe never even explored before. I’m I’ve got like small business owners asking me about Reddit, you know, that were like, wouldn’t have thought about it except they’re seeing all these Reddit sightings.

    Robert Rose (19:06.344)

    Yeah. It’s just remember that AI visibility is kind of a is is is too broad a way to look at it, but unfortunately it’s becoming sort of the du jour way of looking at it. Being mentioned and being cited are two very different content strategies. Being mentioned is just basically getting anything you can get out there to get out there. And being mentioned has very little value. Because remember, getting mentioned might be here’s all the solutions to not purchase, right? And so

    John Jantsch (19:33.336)

    Yeah.

    Robert Rose (19:34.485)

    Just being mentioned is not terribly productive. Being cited, however, being the source of an idea, being the source of something that AI quotes is a great thing. And to your point, that’s becoming, you know, more vocal in communities. It’s becoming covered more in industry journals. It’s becoming covered more on podcasts, on YouTube, on, you know, it’s getting your thought, your you, basically you, the human.

    out into the world more so that the AI finds you and cites you as an a source to an answer.

    John Jantsch (20:05.688)

    So i if you’re a leader of a business listening, what would what would your advice be for obviously you don’t know what they’re doing or where they are or the context, but what what’s typically your advice to a leader of a business of how they need to start thinking differently about AI use and and content today?

    Robert Rose (20:23.882)

    you know, I I start at the very foundational level and I say you need to understand your process first. In other words, understand what how you make marketing because many business owners I find when I ask them about marketing, they go, I don’t know. I got a kid and an agency that handles it and I don’t know how it works. I just I throw an idea in there and stuff comes out the other side. And so you have to understand that how the sausage gets made.

    John Jantsch (20:29.698)

    Yes.

    John Jantsch (20:37.57)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Robert Rose (20:48.776)

    And once you understand how the sausage gets made, you can start to identify places where AI may be able to help you do things either more efficiently, think more deeply, think more creatively, or actually, you know, increase the volume of what it is that you’re doing. But until you understand that, with no standard, there can be no improvement, as Akita Toyota used to say.

    John Jantsch (21:10.892)

    You you know, you mentioned the word process and we could probably do a whole nother show on this. I mean, in a lot of ways, would you suggest that that we actually need instead of looking at AI as a tool, is looking at it as part of the process. The process has to be defined, the outcome has to be defined before you ever plug a tool in.

    Robert Rose (21:28.34)

    Well, that that’s a great point. I mean, it’s yeah, it is a whole other show, which is the thing with AI is is that it’s gotten it’s gotten this rap as a technology and it’s not. It’s like a like it’s like, you know, when somebody says get good at AI, I say, just replace AI with electricity. You know, nobody’s telling you to go get good at electricity, right? It’s like, what does that mean, getting good at AI? What it means is is that you’re probably getting good at some other thing, right? Whether that’s content creation, marketing automation, measurement, you know.

    John Jantsch (21:30.416)

    Ha ha ha.

    John Jantsch (21:51.118)

    Yeah, yeah, yeah.

    Robert Rose (21:55.29)

    Optimization, A B testing, whatever the thing is, that’s where you’re applying AI as a as an overlay, as a and and that’s why understanding the process is such an important thing because it’s like it’s understanding the task that needs to get optimized, not the overall, you know, idea of, you know, the the body of water that encompasses it.

    John Jantsch (22:14.668)

    Yeah, yeah. Well, Robert, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. Is there any anywhere you’d invite people to connect with you and find out more about this research?

    Robert Rose (22:23.518)

    Yeah, please do. It’s LinkedIn is my best place. I’m a I’m a big LinkedIn user, so would love to connect with anybody on LinkedIn and and you know and have a chat about any of this. And of course my website is seventhbear.com.

    John Jantsch (22:36.162)

    Awesome. Well again, appreciate you taking a moment to stop by. Hopefully we’ll run it to you one of these days out there on the road.

    Robert Rose (22:41.95)

    Hundred percent. Yeah, absolutely. Great to see you.

    John Jantsch (22:44.419)

    You too. Take care, Rob.

  • The Buyer Journey in the Age of AI

    The Buyer Journey in the Age of AI written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode: Overview Think about the last time you hired a service you’d never bought before, like a bookkeeper, a lawyer or an ad agency. Chances are you asked Google, a chatbot or a friend long before you talked to a business. In this solo episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, John […]

    How AI Predicts Direct Mail Results written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Brad Kugler, founder of DirectMail2.0. A lot of small business owners wrote off direct mail years ago. Brad explains why a growing group of them is coming back to it, and how AI now lets them estimate a campaign’s response before they spend anything on printing and postage.

    Brad spent twenty-six years in VHS and DVD distribution, until streaming wiped out the category. He rebuilt his career as a technology layer on top of direct mail. His company partners with printers, mail houses and agencies to add tracking, reporting and digital ads aimed at the same households that get the postcard. We talk about why the mailbox gets so much more attention than the inbox, and how variable data printing and QR codes make mail as measurable as any digital channel. We also cover how a database of tens of thousands of past campaigns can flag weak creative and bad timing before a campaign goes out.

    I also hand Brad a real scenario: a Kansas City remodeling contractor with a $20,000 winter budget. He lays out how he’d build an omnichannel campaign for them and what the smallest useful test looks like. If you own or market a local business and have wondered whether direct mail still pays off, this one gives you a practical way to find out.

    Guest bio

    Brad Kugler is a Clearwater, Florida entrepreneur and the founder of DirectMail2.0, now rebranding as DM Intel (Direct Marketing and Intelligence). Before direct mail, Kugler spent twenty-six years running his family’s VHS and DVD media distribution business, from 1990 until streaming ended the category in 2016. He went on to build DirectMail2.0, a white-label platform that adds tracking, reporting and digital ad targeting to direct mail campaigns for printers and agencies. The company acquired the Who’s Mailing What archive. Kugler says the combined data covers more than 80,000 campaigns and 2.2 billion mail pieces, and it powers the company’s AI tools for predicting campaign performance.

    Key takeaways

    • The mailbox is quiet. Most people get three or four pieces of mail a day and hundreds of emails, so a postcard has far less competition for attention.
    • Match the channel to the economics. Mail makes sense when a customer is worth four figures or more over time, like recurring landscaping or jewelry. It makes less sense for selling a few dozen pizzas.
    • Variable data inkjet printing makes one-to-one personalization affordable, which traditional sheet and web presses couldn’t do.
    • Personalized QR codes, text-back numbers and call tracking make a mail piece about as trackable as a digital ad.
    • Geofenced digital ads aimed at the same households can add eight to sixteen extra impressions per mail piece. Kugler puts the cost at roughly 10 to 15 cents more per piece.
    • Kugler reports a typical 25 to 50 percent lift over mail alone, for a 10 to 15 percent increase in cost.
    • Printing and postage are costs you never get back. Testing creative and targeting against past campaign data before you mail is cheap insurance.
    • Timing is part of the offer. A landscaper should mail in February, before homeowners have already hired someone in May.
    • Reach fewer people more often. On a $20,000 budget, Kugler would reach 7,000 households three times rather than 20,000 once.
    • The smallest test worth running is about 2,500 households with three touches. B2B mail works, but it takes more persistence and testing than B2C.

    Great moments

    • [00:11] – Why some small business owners are taking a second look at direct mail
    • [01:13] – Kugler’s first public mention of the rebrand from DirectMail2.0 to DM Intel
    • [02:02] – Going from VHS to streaming, and deciding to be the disruptor this time
    • [03:37] – How a technology layer sits on top of print without printing anything
    • [05:15] – Three pieces of mail versus 300 emails a day
    • [05:44] – The pizza shop rule of thumb for when direct mail pays off
    • [07:16] – Variable data printing, QR codes and call tracking
    • [08:40] – A 25 to 50 percent lift for a 10 to 15 percent increase in cost
    • [10:07] – Building a prediction model from more than 80,000 past campaigns
    • [11:26] – Why a landscaper should mail in February instead of May
    • [12:59] – Live scenario: a Kansas City remodeler with a $20,000 winter budget
    • [15:43] – What’s in the omnichannel bundle: QR codes, an identity pixel, call recording and geofenced ads
    • [18:14] – Reach 7,000 households three times before 20,000 once
    • [19:07] – The smallest direct mail test worth running
    • [19:48] – Why B2B direct mail is harder

    Memorable quotes

    “I needed to re-educate myself, and I needed to be a disruptor and not a disruptee.” – Brad Kugler

    “You go somewhere where everybody else isn’t.” – Kugler

    “You can track a piece of mail like you track a package now down to your doorstep.” – Kugler

    “I would always go for a smaller number who you hit repetitively.” – Kugler

    “At least it gives you a better mousetrap than just going with your gut.” – Kugler

    Resources
    DirectMail2.0 / DM Intel: dm20.com 
    Duct Tape Marketing: ducttapemarketing.com

    John Jantsch (00:11.434)

    So most small businesses, most small business owners at least, wrote off direct mail years ago. Well, right now, a handful of operators are kind of rediscovering it. And the AI tools they’re now able to employ to predict the response before a single piece gets printed. the owners who dismissed the channel maybe now are sitting on data they never bothered to run the numbers on. Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch. My guest today is Brad Kugler. He is a

    Clearwater, Florida entrepreneur who spent two decades running his family’s DVD and media distribution business until, well, streaming video kind of gutted that. rather than go down with the industry, he built Direct Mail 2.0, acquired the direct mail archive of who’s mailing what. I used to get that, and now runs DMI or DM Intel.ai, a connected set of tools that pairs AI prediction with direct mail and digital.

    Cracking. So hopefully I got all that right. Brad, welcome to the show.

    Brad Kugler (01:13.752)

    Thank you, John. Happy to be here. And I have to say this is really the first public announcement of what I’m calling our rebrand from Direct Mail 2.0 to DM Intel, Direct Marketing and Intelligence. again, soft launch, but you got the scoop on that, and I’m happy to talk about it and anything else you like to talk about.

    John Jantsch (01:34.442)

    So I have to tell a little story. There was a little I can’t even call it a D V D store. It was a VHS video store, you know, tape store probably before before your time, even called SRO Video, and I remember it fondly, but yes, they they they they went by the wayside, but gosh darn it, I bet you there’s some some videos that she had down in the basement there that probably have never been put on stream streaming. She had quite an archive.

    Brad Kugler (02:02.662)

    It’s funny, I’ve actually heard of that. You know, I I started in the VHS business in nineteen ninety. Okay. That was probably the tail end of SRO even at that point, but I wrote it all the way from its its sort of big proliferation in the early nineties all the way down to nothing in 2016. And I have to say

    coming to Direct Mail 2.0 or digital marketing is is an interesting story because I was disrupted. You know, I I made the transition from VHS to DVD, great, no problem. But as streaming proliferated after 2010, the writing was on the wall. And I never finished college. I had been in the business since as I said, you know, 26 years. And I’m looking at

    I’m looking at starting a new career with two kids in college. And talk about stressful mortgage, two kids in college. What am I gonna do now? No college degree. Am I even marketable other than being a CEO for a small business? It was it was disconcerting to say the least. And I knew two things. I needed to re-educate myself, and I needed to be a disruptor and not a disruptee.

    John Jantsch (03:21.961)

    Well, you know, I’ve I’ve actually heard you say that or read it somewhere, that line. So I was prepared for you to say that. But on one hand, it’s a little ironic because I think a lot of people would say digital disrupted direct mail. and here you’re back in direct mail, adding a disruptor. So tell me about that.

    Brad Kugler (03:37.807)

    So I I’ll make it real simple. I don’t print or mail anything. I I am a technology layer that sits on top of direct mail. We partner with printers and mail service providers and agencies who do direct mail and we give them a technology edge by providing tracking, reporting tools, and allowing them to digitally target the same people receiving the mail. So in marketing, we all know that it’s repetition.

    You know, it’s repetition that drives home the message. So when you have a piece of direct mail, that’s one piece in the mailbox. Now, if I can deliver ads to the same guy receiving that mail piece for pennies per piece, I’m repeating that message. And here’s the key with direct mail: direct mail being a physical, tactile thing, stays in memory, scientifically proven much longer than a digital ad you have no recollection of seeing in an email or

    browsing the web. So I’m combining the two technologies to sort of create or disrupt direct mail.

    John Jantsch (04:44.787)

    Yeah. So so we’re adding a layer. So this is additive. you know, the because the technology allows us to do that. Go step back just a moment. where where do you feel direct mail sits in general? you know, there there definitely are people said it was dead, and now there’s kind of a a chorus of people starting to say, you know what? Nobody does it anymore. And now we’ve got this other technology, and there’s a lot of other advantages to maybe doing it. So where do you sit on on

    Just the idea of direct mail as a channel.

    Brad Kugler (05:15.436)

    So obviously the bright shiny object gets all the attention. And now email and digital are no longer bright shiny objects. Okay. They’ve been around for a generation. The average person gets six to ten thousand digital images a day. how many pieces are in your mailbox? I get three, maybe four a day. Okay. Yeah. How many emails do you get a day? 300? Yeah. So so here you go.

    John Jantsch (05:18.535)

    Right, right.

    John Jantsch (05:23.081)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (05:34.473)

    Yeah. Yeah. The credit card people have stayed at it. Right. Two thousand. Yeah.

    Brad Kugler (05:44.779)

    You go somewhere where everybody else isn’t. So people are coming back to the mailbox. It’s tactical and it’s tactile and physical. And then you layer on some of the best direct mail, I’m sorry, digital marketing technologies. And now you’ve got a hybrid that’s best of both worlds. Okay. Direct mail has always converted well, but it converts. If I was running a pizza shop, I wouldn’t send a $10,000 direct mail campaign to sell a few dozen pizzas.

    You know, if I’m selling jewelry or landscaping that comes every month for years, now you’ve got a four digit revenue source, it justifies the direct mail. That’s that’s the rule of thumb here.

    John Jantsch (06:28.894)

    What are some of the technologies that people are marrying? You know, obviously the printing technology has changed dramatically. I mean, it used to be, you know, ten up on a sheet, start the presses, ink up, go. You know, and now with all of this digital printing, I mean, you know, you see personalization, you see different images, you know, on different I mean, so what has the technology really done to the effectiveness of direct mail?

    Brad Kugler (06:48.908)

    Yeah. So so you you’re well versed and obviously the technology has improved in the direct mail. You can you can have variable data presses that can you know personalize a postcard one to one. So and and there’s no real additional cost in investing in the in the infrastructure in the first place. It’s you could never do that with a sheet or a web press. It’s impossible.

    John Jantsch (07:15.668)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Brad Kugler (07:16.642)

    But you can do that with variable data inkjets. And you know, pretty much if you’re in the business now, you got one. So you can do that. Any type of personalization segmentation helps with targeting, it helps with relevancy. So that’s a that’s a plus. Now, if you start combining that with personalized QR codes, text back numbers, call tracking, you can track a piece of mail like you track a package now down to your doorstep. So you’ve got tools that make direct mail.

    as immediately quantifiable and reportable as any digital product at this point. So so it’s caught up to the digital products. where people need help is deploying an omnichannel campaign.

    systemically or systematically with a with a print campaign, it’s a lot of moving parts. So this is where guys like me coming in that automate that process, time the campaign deployments, time all of the reporting and the digital deployment of digital ad targeting. And now you’ve got a real product that’s easily deployable from for one or two phone calls rather than calling five different guys and agencies. So that it that’s what it is. It’s it’s all technology driven.

    John Jantsch (08:26.176)

    Right.

    John Jantsch (08:32.042)

    So I assume there’s a a cost involved in employing your platform. So what kind of lifts are you seeing and why?

    Brad Kugler (08:40.793)

    We’re seeing usually 25 to 50% over direct mail alone. And and this is this is the real simple elevator pitch. If I can get you a 25 to 50% lift in your direct mail responses for a 10 to 15% increase in cost, does that work for you? I mean, it’s a no-brainer. If would you make an investment like that? And we’re seeing that. And and again.

    And I sure I’m sure being a marketing guy, you know, there’s no guarantees in marketing. There’s so many variables that somebody could have a have a have a flat campaign and it does happen. And but for the most case, we do see a lift for a very small increase in price. And if nothing else, the reporting you’re getting and the targeting visibility and transparency you’re getting with our reporting will help you correct those mistakes in the next mailing.

    But like any marketing campaign, there’s gotta be a little repetition. There’s gotta be a staying partner. It’s not a one and done and all of a sudden all the leads run in. You gotta stick with it a little bit, like any type of campaign.

    John Jantsch (09:35.136)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (09:40.609)

    So one of the things I’ve seen as people have moved back to direct mail is there’s a a lot of the everydoor stuff that that people are doing because it’s, you know, in theory it’s cheaper. I would say twenty five to thirty percent of it goes in every trash can before it gets to a door. But what what does the predictive modeling, you know, do to to actually save, you know, on on printing costs in general and and postage costs?

    Brad Kugler (09:55.756)

    At least

    Brad Kugler (10:07.001)

    So let let me take a step back and explain what our predictive modeling is. We we’ve launched over 80,000 direct mail campaigns, 2.2 billion pieces of mail in 157 different verticals. We have kept all that data. I knew it would be valuable someday, and I believe with the acquisition of who’s mailing what, we have the largest database of direct mail marketing in the world.

    So, what we’ve done with that database, because 20,000 of those campaigns can carry results, who engaged with those campaigns? How were they engaged in? So we can take a piece of creative, we can take your targeting that you’re intending to do. And before you spend the money on the print and mail, which are hard cost, never to be recouped, you can feed that data into our model.

    John Jantsch (10:55.008)

    Mm-hmm.

    Brad Kugler (10:57.717)

    And it will give you back a kind of benchmark. If the benchmark for a credit card campaign comes at this level, we can dissect your campaign and predict based on past results, is it going to perform better, equal, or worse? And what can you do to perform better? sometimes an easy example is add a QR code, it gives you a 3% lift. make your headline bigger, offer something free. If you’re a landscaper, for instance,

    John Jantsch (11:18.197)

    Mm-hmm.

    Brad Kugler (11:26.433)

    Start doing your mailing in February rather than May, you know, when people have already found someone. So some of it’s obvious, but some of it is very specific for that cohort, that cohort of who you’re targeting and what vertical you’re in because of all of our past history. So the savings can be infinite. If you’ve got a campaign that’s just time-wronged and creative-wronged, and we avert some of those with our recommendations.

    John Jantsch (11:43.071)

    Brad Kugler (11:52.996)

    Well, you’ve saved the entire cost of the mailing and not recompensed anything, you know. again, no guarantees. It’s all probability rated based on past experience, but past results do not guarantee future results. But at least it gives you a better mousetrap than just going it from your gut, you know?

    John Jantsch (12:14.25)

    So you were rolling this out, I think, as a as kind of a white label for agencies, is that kind of the model or

    Brad Kugler (12:19.201)

    Well, the predictive modeling we’re doing under our own label. But for the omnichannel marketing suite for pr for for direct mail, yes, that is white labeled. So if you’re a cut commercial printer or an agency, you know, they don’t ever have to know who we are. You can label it, tweak the campaigns, manage them yourself, and resell it. we offer it what we think is a wholesale, and there’s

    room on the bone, left there’s more meat on the bone so that you can make a margin on it. So we’re trying to be that guy that helps the printers and agencies add a revenue and a profit center to their business.

    John Jantsch (12:59.336)

    All right, so I gave you a little heads up on this, fair warning, but I’m gonna throw out a typical sort of B2C, hyperlocal example and and just kind of how you would approach the omni channel, you know, idea behind this. So I’ll I’ll read off what I wrote to you. So I’ve got a client that’s looking for handyman leads or actually a modeling contractor or they have a handyman division. In the winter, that business slows down sometimes.

    they’ve got a twenty thousand dollar budget. they are in a metro s midsized metro area, Kansas City, Missouri, mostly upscale work or is is the work that they do. They’ve already considered some radio and direct mail. but walk me through how you would if you were advising them, how would you how would you design the that entire campaign?

    Brad Kugler (13:48.399)

    Well, you know, without kind of selling my own products here, I would definitely say feed your proposed campaign into our predictive modeling. Not only will it predict the outcome based on benchmarks of that industry for that time period, for that geography, it’ll also show you what the competitors are offering.

    And and why is that useful? Like let’s say a competitor’s offering, buy a five-hour block of handyman time, you know, for 350 bucks, we’ll sell it to you for 250. You know, they can see if anybody’s got a similar offer or or what other handyman services are being offered in that locale. So the the the point of knowledge being power is key here. And we have the largest database of other direct mail offerings.

    So, not only are you going to get a prediction on how well your mailpiece is going to do before you spend a penny on mailing it, so you can tweak it, but you can also see what competitors are offering for similar products in a similar area. So that for sure. As far as economies for scale, our omnichannel platform, dm20.com, will combine a lot of these digital products with the mailing products, and it will

    obviously save you time and resources. You are not an agency. You don’t have a team there who can actually manage and you know initiate these campaigns. We can do it in a few clicks. So we’re offering people that do not have in-house marketing teams the avail to basically have an agency in a box by using us. So there’s a lot of benefits and and obviously if we weren’t adding to somebody’s

    bottom line and top line with our campaigns, we wouldn’t b have been around for nine years already. So and now with the AI tools we’ve built, I think we’re just a better mousetrap, improving all the time.

    John Jantsch (15:38.381)

    So so again, part of what I was trying getting at is what would an omni channel approach for for that type of thing look like? Yeah.

    Brad Kugler (15:43.869)

    I see. So so the bundle would be this. Rather than just a postcard in the mail, we would have trackable QR codes added to every piece. We would track who goes to the website and what we do with our de-anonymizing pixel or identity resolution pixel. We’re able to tell you which of those people you mailed to actually made it to the website. So you can track conversions. If they call

    Or you want to do a text pan campaign, we’ll record those call transactions and engagements. We even record the phone calls to your office that again is perfectly secure that only you can see. So maybe you’ve got somebody at the front desk who’s burning the leads as they come in. At least they’re trackable and at least they’re memorialized so you can go back to them and recover those failed closes. not to mention a social media campaign. We’re doing a

    geofenced campaign that will target the same households that are getting the mail. So if if they’re getting one piece of mail in the mailbox, we’re hoping they get eight to sixteen additional impressions digitally between Meta, that’s Instagram and Facebook, Google, they’re getting additional campaigns. So it stays top of mind. So we’re doing all of that for an extra maybe 10 to 15 cents per piece.

    John Jantsch (17:03.125)

    And that’s y you would provide the list as part of that as well, because that’s no.

    Brad Kugler (17:07.502)

    No, the the list we can help with that. It’s not included in that price. So we can either get them the list or you know, assuming that they’ve mailed before, maybe they have a list or the commercial printer they’re using as a list. The list the list acquisition is easy. You know, you tell me what kind of household you’re getting. There’s thousands of people that can procure that in seconds.

    John Jantsch (17:10.603)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (17:28.373)

    Yeah, yeah. but again, that’s that seems like that’s a key component to the Omni part, right? Yeah, yeah.

    Brad Kugler (17:34.273)

    It it absolutely is. And in fact, there’s so many vendors of that. We’ve we’ve vacillated on do we want to offer this too? I mean it’s it’s a commodity. List brokerage now is a commodity. You can go to a website and put in your it it’ll go and search your customers and it will come up with your ICP. It feeds at this point it’s a pretty easy thing to acquire. And you know, to make five percent on that, I don’t know that it’s worth it when most people already have a source for that.

    But we can help if someone doesn’t have that.

    John Jantsch (18:06.017)

    All right, so so a business owner well, I one last question on that. I is that twenty thousand budget realistic for that type of thing or yeah, okay.

    Brad Kugler (18:14.125)

    absolutely. I mean if you’re I’m gonna assume a dollar a target, so you can either hit twenty thousand people one time or you could what I would prefer is they hit seven thousand people three times. Okay. Again, it’s that repetitive message. I would always go for a smaller number who you hit repetitively.

    John Jantsch (18:34.879)

    Yeah. And the nice thing about a local business like that is that they probably can actually target by even even smaller than zips.

    Brad Kugler (18:42.691)

    yeah, you can go specific households. Now you’re not gonna get E D DM that way, but you’re gonna pay a little more for postage, but you’re gonna target guys that are homeowners versus renters. You’re gonna target guys that are gonna really it’s a better targeting operation.

    John Jantsch (18:47.881)

    No. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (18:53.611)

    Yeah. Right, right.

    John Jantsch (18:58.069)

    Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So if if if I’m a business owner who still thinks direct mail is dead, what’s what’s the smallest test that could run th th this winter?

    Brad Kugler (19:07.445)

    You know, that’s a great people ask us that all the time. And and and a lot of people say, well, why don’t we try a hundred? And I’m like, man, you know, go see what Google says if you want to target a hundred people. They’ll they’ll laugh at you, you know. we like to see at least 2,500 on a target, and we like to see at least hitting them three times. That’ll give you an indication of of your marketing, is it hitting or not? And you can try something else. But that’s that’s we’ usually what we recommend.

    John Jantsch (19:13.281)

    Yeah.

    Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (19:23.435)

    Yep, okay.

    John Jantsch (19:35.521)

    Do you find that B to B, B to C, you know, mo I think most people think of direct mail as B to C are you finding any success in for that accounting firm or that law firm that’s targeting businesses?

    Brad Kugler (19:48.311)

    I I’ll be honest with you, B2C is trickier because you’re trying to find those people. I’m sorry, B you’re right. B2B is trickier. B2B is definitely trickier because you can try to target them at their home, which is easy to, you know, with data service, you can find them. Or you risk sending it to a business and that thing makes it to the trash before it makes it to any decision makers’ eyes. So you you you have additional challenges B2C with direct mail. It’s doable, people are getting success.

    John Jantsch (19:53.909)

    You mean B to B is trickier. Yeah, okay, yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (20:09.599)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Brad Kugler (20:16.702)

    It involves a little more persistence in testing than the B to C does.

    John Jantsch (20:21.141)

    Yeah. Well, Brad, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast and talk direct mail. Where where would you have people find out more about what you’re doing and connect with you?

    Brad Kugler (20:31.501)

    the easiest thing to remember is dm two zero dot com. That’s dm two zero dot com. It it it’ll show all of our direct mail and direct marketing related features there and I’m easy to find from there. LinkedIn, I’m I’m pretty well known there too.

    John Jantsch (20:47.649)

    Awesome. Awesome. Well again, appreciate you taking a moment and hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road.

    Brad Kugler (20:54.211)

    I hope so. Thanks, John. It’s been a pleasure.

  • How AI Predicts Direct Mail Results

    How AI Predicts Direct Mail Results written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode: Overview On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Brad Kugler, founder of DirectMail2.0. A lot of small business owners wrote off direct mail years ago. Brad explains why a growing group of them is coming back to it, and how AI now lets them estimate a […]

    How AI Predicts Direct Mail Results written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, I talk with Brad Kugler, founder of DirectMail2.0. A lot of small business owners wrote off direct mail years ago. Brad explains why a growing group of them is coming back to it, and how AI now lets them estimate a campaign’s response before they spend anything on printing and postage.

    Brad spent twenty-six years in VHS and DVD distribution, until streaming wiped out the category. He rebuilt his career as a technology layer on top of direct mail. His company partners with printers, mail houses and agencies to add tracking, reporting and digital ads aimed at the same households that get the postcard. We talk about why the mailbox gets so much more attention than the inbox, and how variable data printing and QR codes make mail as measurable as any digital channel. We also cover how a database of tens of thousands of past campaigns can flag weak creative and bad timing before a campaign goes out.

    I also hand Brad a real scenario: a Kansas City remodeling contractor with a $20,000 winter budget. He lays out how he’d build an omnichannel campaign for them and what the smallest useful test looks like. If you own or market a local business and have wondered whether direct mail still pays off, this one gives you a practical way to find out.

    Guest bio

    Brad Kugler is a Clearwater, Florida entrepreneur and the founder of DirectMail2.0, now rebranding as DM Intel (Direct Marketing and Intelligence). Before direct mail, Kugler spent twenty-six years running his family’s VHS and DVD media distribution business, from 1990 until streaming ended the category in 2016. He went on to build DirectMail2.0, a white-label platform that adds tracking, reporting and digital ad targeting to direct mail campaigns for printers and agencies. The company acquired the Who’s Mailing What archive. Kugler says the combined data covers more than 80,000 campaigns and 2.2 billion mail pieces, and it powers the company’s AI tools for predicting campaign performance.

    Key takeaways

    • The mailbox is quiet. Most people get three or four pieces of mail a day and hundreds of emails, so a postcard has far less competition for attention.
    • Match the channel to the economics. Mail makes sense when a customer is worth four figures or more over time, like recurring landscaping or jewelry. It makes less sense for selling a few dozen pizzas.
    • Variable data inkjet printing makes one-to-one personalization affordable, which traditional sheet and web presses couldn’t do.
    • Personalized QR codes, text-back numbers and call tracking make a mail piece about as trackable as a digital ad.
    • Geofenced digital ads aimed at the same households can add eight to sixteen extra impressions per mail piece. Kugler puts the cost at roughly 10 to 15 cents more per piece.
    • Kugler reports a typical 25 to 50 percent lift over mail alone, for a 10 to 15 percent increase in cost.
    • Printing and postage are costs you never get back. Testing creative and targeting against past campaign data before you mail is cheap insurance.
    • Timing is part of the offer. A landscaper should mail in February, before homeowners have already hired someone in May.
    • Reach fewer people more often. On a $20,000 budget, Kugler would reach 7,000 households three times rather than 20,000 once.
    • The smallest test worth running is about 2,500 households with three touches. B2B mail works, but it takes more persistence and testing than B2C.

    Great moments

    • [00:11] – Why some small business owners are taking a second look at direct mail
    • [01:13] – Kugler’s first public mention of the rebrand from DirectMail2.0 to DM Intel
    • [02:02] – Going from VHS to streaming, and deciding to be the disruptor this time
    • [03:37] – How a technology layer sits on top of print without printing anything
    • [05:15] – Three pieces of mail versus 300 emails a day
    • [05:44] – The pizza shop rule of thumb for when direct mail pays off
    • [07:16] – Variable data printing, QR codes and call tracking
    • [08:40] – A 25 to 50 percent lift for a 10 to 15 percent increase in cost
    • [10:07] – Building a prediction model from more than 80,000 past campaigns
    • [11:26] – Why a landscaper should mail in February instead of May
    • [12:59] – Live scenario: a Kansas City remodeler with a $20,000 winter budget
    • [15:43] – What’s in the omnichannel bundle: QR codes, an identity pixel, call recording and geofenced ads
    • [18:14] – Reach 7,000 households three times before 20,000 once
    • [19:07] – The smallest direct mail test worth running
    • [19:48] – Why B2B direct mail is harder

    Memorable quotes

    “I needed to re-educate myself, and I needed to be a disruptor and not a disruptee.” – Brad Kugler

    “You go somewhere where everybody else isn’t.” – Kugler

    “You can track a piece of mail like you track a package now down to your doorstep.” – Kugler

    “I would always go for a smaller number who you hit repetitively.” – Kugler

    “At least it gives you a better mousetrap than just going with your gut.” – Kugler

    Resources
    DirectMail2.0 / DM Intel: dm20.com 
    Duct Tape Marketing: ducttapemarketing.com

    John Jantsch (00:11.434)

    So most small businesses, most small business owners at least, wrote off direct mail years ago. Well, right now, a handful of operators are kind of rediscovering it. And the AI tools they’re now able to employ to predict the response before a single piece gets printed. the owners who dismissed the channel maybe now are sitting on data they never bothered to run the numbers on. Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch. My guest today is Brad Kugler. He is a

    Clearwater, Florida entrepreneur who spent two decades running his family’s DVD and media distribution business until, well, streaming video kind of gutted that. rather than go down with the industry, he built Direct Mail 2.0, acquired the direct mail archive of who’s mailing what. I used to get that, and now runs DMI or DM Intel.ai, a connected set of tools that pairs AI prediction with direct mail and digital.

    Cracking. So hopefully I got all that right. Brad, welcome to the show.

    Brad Kugler (01:13.752)

    Thank you, John. Happy to be here. And I have to say this is really the first public announcement of what I’m calling our rebrand from Direct Mail 2.0 to DM Intel, Direct Marketing and Intelligence. again, soft launch, but you got the scoop on that, and I’m happy to talk about it and anything else you like to talk about.

    John Jantsch (01:34.442)

    So I have to tell a little story. There was a little I can’t even call it a D V D store. It was a VHS video store, you know, tape store probably before before your time, even called SRO Video, and I remember it fondly, but yes, they they they they went by the wayside, but gosh darn it, I bet you there’s some some videos that she had down in the basement there that probably have never been put on stream streaming. She had quite an archive.

    Brad Kugler (02:02.662)

    It’s funny, I’ve actually heard of that. You know, I I started in the VHS business in nineteen ninety. Okay. That was probably the tail end of SRO even at that point, but I wrote it all the way from its its sort of big proliferation in the early nineties all the way down to nothing in 2016. And I have to say

    coming to Direct Mail 2.0 or digital marketing is is an interesting story because I was disrupted. You know, I I made the transition from VHS to DVD, great, no problem. But as streaming proliferated after 2010, the writing was on the wall. And I never finished college. I had been in the business since as I said, you know, 26 years. And I’m looking at

    I’m looking at starting a new career with two kids in college. And talk about stressful mortgage, two kids in college. What am I gonna do now? No college degree. Am I even marketable other than being a CEO for a small business? It was it was disconcerting to say the least. And I knew two things. I needed to re-educate myself, and I needed to be a disruptor and not a disruptee.

    John Jantsch (03:21.961)

    Well, you know, I’ve I’ve actually heard you say that or read it somewhere, that line. So I was prepared for you to say that. But on one hand, it’s a little ironic because I think a lot of people would say digital disrupted direct mail. and here you’re back in direct mail, adding a disruptor. So tell me about that.

    Brad Kugler (03:37.807)

    So I I’ll make it real simple. I don’t print or mail anything. I I am a technology layer that sits on top of direct mail. We partner with printers and mail service providers and agencies who do direct mail and we give them a technology edge by providing tracking, reporting tools, and allowing them to digitally target the same people receiving the mail. So in marketing, we all know that it’s repetition.

    You know, it’s repetition that drives home the message. So when you have a piece of direct mail, that’s one piece in the mailbox. Now, if I can deliver ads to the same guy receiving that mail piece for pennies per piece, I’m repeating that message. And here’s the key with direct mail: direct mail being a physical, tactile thing, stays in memory, scientifically proven much longer than a digital ad you have no recollection of seeing in an email or

    browsing the web. So I’m combining the two technologies to sort of create or disrupt direct mail.

    John Jantsch (04:44.787)

    Yeah. So so we’re adding a layer. So this is additive. you know, the because the technology allows us to do that. Go step back just a moment. where where do you feel direct mail sits in general? you know, there there definitely are people said it was dead, and now there’s kind of a a chorus of people starting to say, you know what? Nobody does it anymore. And now we’ve got this other technology, and there’s a lot of other advantages to maybe doing it. So where do you sit on on

    Just the idea of direct mail as a channel.

    Brad Kugler (05:15.436)

    So obviously the bright shiny object gets all the attention. And now email and digital are no longer bright shiny objects. Okay. They’ve been around for a generation. The average person gets six to ten thousand digital images a day. how many pieces are in your mailbox? I get three, maybe four a day. Okay. Yeah. How many emails do you get a day? 300? Yeah. So so here you go.

    John Jantsch (05:18.535)

    Right, right.

    John Jantsch (05:23.081)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (05:34.473)

    Yeah. Yeah. The credit card people have stayed at it. Right. Two thousand. Yeah.

    Brad Kugler (05:44.779)

    You go somewhere where everybody else isn’t. So people are coming back to the mailbox. It’s tactical and it’s tactile and physical. And then you layer on some of the best direct mail, I’m sorry, digital marketing technologies. And now you’ve got a hybrid that’s best of both worlds. Okay. Direct mail has always converted well, but it converts. If I was running a pizza shop, I wouldn’t send a $10,000 direct mail campaign to sell a few dozen pizzas.

    You know, if I’m selling jewelry or landscaping that comes every month for years, now you’ve got a four digit revenue source, it justifies the direct mail. That’s that’s the rule of thumb here.

    John Jantsch (06:28.894)

    What are some of the technologies that people are marrying? You know, obviously the printing technology has changed dramatically. I mean, it used to be, you know, ten up on a sheet, start the presses, ink up, go. You know, and now with all of this digital printing, I mean, you know, you see personalization, you see different images, you know, on different I mean, so what has the technology really done to the effectiveness of direct mail?

    Brad Kugler (06:48.908)

    Yeah. So so you you’re well versed and obviously the technology has improved in the direct mail. You can you can have variable data presses that can you know personalize a postcard one to one. So and and there’s no real additional cost in investing in the in the infrastructure in the first place. It’s you could never do that with a sheet or a web press. It’s impossible.

    John Jantsch (07:15.668)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    Brad Kugler (07:16.642)

    But you can do that with variable data inkjets. And you know, pretty much if you’re in the business now, you got one. So you can do that. Any type of personalization segmentation helps with targeting, it helps with relevancy. So that’s a that’s a plus. Now, if you start combining that with personalized QR codes, text back numbers, call tracking, you can track a piece of mail like you track a package now down to your doorstep. So you’ve got tools that make direct mail.

    as immediately quantifiable and reportable as any digital product at this point. So so it’s caught up to the digital products. where people need help is deploying an omnichannel campaign.

    systemically or systematically with a with a print campaign, it’s a lot of moving parts. So this is where guys like me coming in that automate that process, time the campaign deployments, time all of the reporting and the digital deployment of digital ad targeting. And now you’ve got a real product that’s easily deployable from for one or two phone calls rather than calling five different guys and agencies. So that it that’s what it is. It’s it’s all technology driven.

    John Jantsch (08:26.176)

    Right.

    John Jantsch (08:32.042)

    So I assume there’s a a cost involved in employing your platform. So what kind of lifts are you seeing and why?

    Brad Kugler (08:40.793)

    We’re seeing usually 25 to 50% over direct mail alone. And and this is this is the real simple elevator pitch. If I can get you a 25 to 50% lift in your direct mail responses for a 10 to 15% increase in cost, does that work for you? I mean, it’s a no-brainer. If would you make an investment like that? And we’re seeing that. And and again.

    And I sure I’m sure being a marketing guy, you know, there’s no guarantees in marketing. There’s so many variables that somebody could have a have a have a flat campaign and it does happen. And but for the most case, we do see a lift for a very small increase in price. And if nothing else, the reporting you’re getting and the targeting visibility and transparency you’re getting with our reporting will help you correct those mistakes in the next mailing.

    But like any marketing campaign, there’s gotta be a little repetition. There’s gotta be a staying partner. It’s not a one and done and all of a sudden all the leads run in. You gotta stick with it a little bit, like any type of campaign.

    John Jantsch (09:35.136)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (09:40.609)

    So one of the things I’ve seen as people have moved back to direct mail is there’s a a lot of the everydoor stuff that that people are doing because it’s, you know, in theory it’s cheaper. I would say twenty five to thirty percent of it goes in every trash can before it gets to a door. But what what does the predictive modeling, you know, do to to actually save, you know, on on printing costs in general and and postage costs?

    Brad Kugler (09:55.756)

    At least

    Brad Kugler (10:07.001)

    So let let me take a step back and explain what our predictive modeling is. We we’ve launched over 80,000 direct mail campaigns, 2.2 billion pieces of mail in 157 different verticals. We have kept all that data. I knew it would be valuable someday, and I believe with the acquisition of who’s mailing what, we have the largest database of direct mail marketing in the world.

    So, what we’ve done with that database, because 20,000 of those campaigns can carry results, who engaged with those campaigns? How were they engaged in? So we can take a piece of creative, we can take your targeting that you’re intending to do. And before you spend the money on the print and mail, which are hard cost, never to be recouped, you can feed that data into our model.

    John Jantsch (10:55.008)

    Mm-hmm.

    Brad Kugler (10:57.717)

    And it will give you back a kind of benchmark. If the benchmark for a credit card campaign comes at this level, we can dissect your campaign and predict based on past results, is it going to perform better, equal, or worse? And what can you do to perform better? sometimes an easy example is add a QR code, it gives you a 3% lift. make your headline bigger, offer something free. If you’re a landscaper, for instance,

    John Jantsch (11:18.197)

    Mm-hmm.

    Brad Kugler (11:26.433)

    Start doing your mailing in February rather than May, you know, when people have already found someone. So some of it’s obvious, but some of it is very specific for that cohort, that cohort of who you’re targeting and what vertical you’re in because of all of our past history. So the savings can be infinite. If you’ve got a campaign that’s just time-wronged and creative-wronged, and we avert some of those with our recommendations.

    John Jantsch (11:43.071)

    Brad Kugler (11:52.996)

    Well, you’ve saved the entire cost of the mailing and not recompensed anything, you know. again, no guarantees. It’s all probability rated based on past experience, but past results do not guarantee future results. But at least it gives you a better mousetrap than just going it from your gut, you know?

    John Jantsch (12:14.25)

    So you were rolling this out, I think, as a as kind of a white label for agencies, is that kind of the model or

    Brad Kugler (12:19.201)

    Well, the predictive modeling we’re doing under our own label. But for the omnichannel marketing suite for pr for for direct mail, yes, that is white labeled. So if you’re a cut commercial printer or an agency, you know, they don’t ever have to know who we are. You can label it, tweak the campaigns, manage them yourself, and resell it. we offer it what we think is a wholesale, and there’s

    room on the bone, left there’s more meat on the bone so that you can make a margin on it. So we’re trying to be that guy that helps the printers and agencies add a revenue and a profit center to their business.

    John Jantsch (12:59.336)

    All right, so I gave you a little heads up on this, fair warning, but I’m gonna throw out a typical sort of B2C, hyperlocal example and and just kind of how you would approach the omni channel, you know, idea behind this. So I’ll I’ll read off what I wrote to you. So I’ve got a client that’s looking for handyman leads or actually a modeling contractor or they have a handyman division. In the winter, that business slows down sometimes.

    they’ve got a twenty thousand dollar budget. they are in a metro s midsized metro area, Kansas City, Missouri, mostly upscale work or is is the work that they do. They’ve already considered some radio and direct mail. but walk me through how you would if you were advising them, how would you how would you design the that entire campaign?

    Brad Kugler (13:48.399)

    Well, you know, without kind of selling my own products here, I would definitely say feed your proposed campaign into our predictive modeling. Not only will it predict the outcome based on benchmarks of that industry for that time period, for that geography, it’ll also show you what the competitors are offering.

    And and why is that useful? Like let’s say a competitor’s offering, buy a five-hour block of handyman time, you know, for 350 bucks, we’ll sell it to you for 250. You know, they can see if anybody’s got a similar offer or or what other handyman services are being offered in that locale. So the the the point of knowledge being power is key here. And we have the largest database of other direct mail offerings.

    So, not only are you going to get a prediction on how well your mailpiece is going to do before you spend a penny on mailing it, so you can tweak it, but you can also see what competitors are offering for similar products in a similar area. So that for sure. As far as economies for scale, our omnichannel platform, dm20.com, will combine a lot of these digital products with the mailing products, and it will

    obviously save you time and resources. You are not an agency. You don’t have a team there who can actually manage and you know initiate these campaigns. We can do it in a few clicks. So we’re offering people that do not have in-house marketing teams the avail to basically have an agency in a box by using us. So there’s a lot of benefits and and obviously if we weren’t adding to somebody’s

    bottom line and top line with our campaigns, we wouldn’t b have been around for nine years already. So and now with the AI tools we’ve built, I think we’re just a better mousetrap, improving all the time.

    John Jantsch (15:38.381)

    So so again, part of what I was trying getting at is what would an omni channel approach for for that type of thing look like? Yeah.

    Brad Kugler (15:43.869)

    I see. So so the bundle would be this. Rather than just a postcard in the mail, we would have trackable QR codes added to every piece. We would track who goes to the website and what we do with our de-anonymizing pixel or identity resolution pixel. We’re able to tell you which of those people you mailed to actually made it to the website. So you can track conversions. If they call

    Or you want to do a text pan campaign, we’ll record those call transactions and engagements. We even record the phone calls to your office that again is perfectly secure that only you can see. So maybe you’ve got somebody at the front desk who’s burning the leads as they come in. At least they’re trackable and at least they’re memorialized so you can go back to them and recover those failed closes. not to mention a social media campaign. We’re doing a

    geofenced campaign that will target the same households that are getting the mail. So if if they’re getting one piece of mail in the mailbox, we’re hoping they get eight to sixteen additional impressions digitally between Meta, that’s Instagram and Facebook, Google, they’re getting additional campaigns. So it stays top of mind. So we’re doing all of that for an extra maybe 10 to 15 cents per piece.

    John Jantsch (17:03.125)

    And that’s y you would provide the list as part of that as well, because that’s no.

    Brad Kugler (17:07.502)

    No, the the list we can help with that. It’s not included in that price. So we can either get them the list or you know, assuming that they’ve mailed before, maybe they have a list or the commercial printer they’re using as a list. The list the list acquisition is easy. You know, you tell me what kind of household you’re getting. There’s thousands of people that can procure that in seconds.

    John Jantsch (17:10.603)

    Yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (17:28.373)

    Yeah, yeah. but again, that’s that seems like that’s a key component to the Omni part, right? Yeah, yeah.

    Brad Kugler (17:34.273)

    It it absolutely is. And in fact, there’s so many vendors of that. We’ve we’ve vacillated on do we want to offer this too? I mean it’s it’s a commodity. List brokerage now is a commodity. You can go to a website and put in your it it’ll go and search your customers and it will come up with your ICP. It feeds at this point it’s a pretty easy thing to acquire. And you know, to make five percent on that, I don’t know that it’s worth it when most people already have a source for that.

    But we can help if someone doesn’t have that.

    John Jantsch (18:06.017)

    All right, so so a business owner well, I one last question on that. I is that twenty thousand budget realistic for that type of thing or yeah, okay.

    Brad Kugler (18:14.125)

    absolutely. I mean if you’re I’m gonna assume a dollar a target, so you can either hit twenty thousand people one time or you could what I would prefer is they hit seven thousand people three times. Okay. Again, it’s that repetitive message. I would always go for a smaller number who you hit repetitively.

    John Jantsch (18:34.879)

    Yeah. And the nice thing about a local business like that is that they probably can actually target by even even smaller than zips.

    Brad Kugler (18:42.691)

    yeah, you can go specific households. Now you’re not gonna get E D DM that way, but you’re gonna pay a little more for postage, but you’re gonna target guys that are homeowners versus renters. You’re gonna target guys that are gonna really it’s a better targeting operation.

    John Jantsch (18:47.881)

    No. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (18:53.611)

    Yeah. Right, right.

    John Jantsch (18:58.069)

    Yeah, yeah, absolutely. So if if if I’m a business owner who still thinks direct mail is dead, what’s what’s the smallest test that could run th th this winter?

    Brad Kugler (19:07.445)

    You know, that’s a great people ask us that all the time. And and and a lot of people say, well, why don’t we try a hundred? And I’m like, man, you know, go see what Google says if you want to target a hundred people. They’ll they’ll laugh at you, you know. we like to see at least 2,500 on a target, and we like to see at least hitting them three times. That’ll give you an indication of of your marketing, is it hitting or not? And you can try something else. But that’s that’s we’ usually what we recommend.

    John Jantsch (19:13.281)

    Yeah.

    Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (19:23.435)

    Yep, okay.

    John Jantsch (19:35.521)

    Do you find that B to B, B to C, you know, mo I think most people think of direct mail as B to C are you finding any success in for that accounting firm or that law firm that’s targeting businesses?

    Brad Kugler (19:48.311)

    I I’ll be honest with you, B2C is trickier because you’re trying to find those people. I’m sorry, B you’re right. B2B is trickier. B2B is definitely trickier because you can try to target them at their home, which is easy to, you know, with data service, you can find them. Or you risk sending it to a business and that thing makes it to the trash before it makes it to any decision makers’ eyes. So you you you have additional challenges B2C with direct mail. It’s doable, people are getting success.

    John Jantsch (19:53.909)

    You mean B to B is trickier. Yeah, okay, yeah. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (20:09.599)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Brad Kugler (20:16.702)

    It involves a little more persistence in testing than the B to C does.

    John Jantsch (20:21.141)

    Yeah. Well, Brad, I appreciate you taking a moment to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast and talk direct mail. Where where would you have people find out more about what you’re doing and connect with you?

    Brad Kugler (20:31.501)

    the easiest thing to remember is dm two zero dot com. That’s dm two zero dot com. It it it’ll show all of our direct mail and direct marketing related features there and I’m easy to find from there. LinkedIn, I’m I’m pretty well known there too.

    John Jantsch (20:47.649)

    Awesome. Awesome. Well again, appreciate you taking a moment and hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road.

    Brad Kugler (20:54.211)

    I hope so. Thanks, John. It’s been a pleasure.

  • How to Build Executive Presence and Communicate With Confidence

    How to Build Executive Presence and Communicate With Confidence written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the full episode Overview On this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast I talk with Gina London. She’s an Emmy-winning former CNN correspondent, CEO of Language of Leadership, and author of Amplify You: How to Connect More Powerfully in an AI World. AI can draft your pitch and polish your deck, but you […]

    Where AI Belongs in Your Business written by Jordan E read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    Ryan Levesque, founder of the ASK Method, smiling in a light blue plaid shirt on a navy background beside the Duct Tape Marketing logo. Episode: What Should You Automate With AI, and What Should Stay Human? featuring guest Ryan Levesque and host John Jantsch on the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast.

    This one’s back from the vault. AI tools keep piling up, so the question John Jantsch and Ryan Levesque take on here matters more now than when it first aired. Where should AI save you time, and where does a personal touch let you charge more?

    Levesque runs AI every day inside his own company. He explains how he decides what gets automated (the back office comes first) and what he won’t hand off. He and Jantsch also get into why work that doesn’t scale can set you apart and how letting customers see your process supports higher prices. Levesque also shares a 30-second morning habit that shapes the rest of his day.

    Running a consultancy, an agency or a growing business? You’ll walk away with ideas you can test this week.

    Guest Bio

    Ryan Levesque has built and exited 2 companies with a combined value of more than $100 million, and he’s made the Inc. 5000 list 7 times as CEO. He wrote Ask, a No. 1 national bestseller and Inc.’s marketing book of the year, and he founded the ASK Method. His latest book is Return to Real: The Last Human Advantage in an Age of Artificial Everything. In it he argues that the things our bodies and spirits are hungry for are the same things customers will pay a premium for.

    Key Takeaways

    • Point AI at the back office first, the work that sits furthest from your customer. The email sequences and social posts that make your first impression need a human voice.
    • Choose a few moments that won’t scale and handle them yourself. A voice memo to every new customer or a handwritten note to every new client shows a kind of care software can’t fake.
    • Show your work. Let customers see how things get made and who makes them. The story behind the work is part of what they pay for.
    • Make something before you scroll. Use the first minutes of your day, while your head is clear, to write or build before email and social media pull you in.
    • Publish your own thinking on a schedule. For nearly 2.5 years Levesque has sent a weekly email, often 2,000 to 4,000 words long. He credits it with bringing in more opportunity than anything else he’s done in 20 years of business.

    Great Moments

    • [04:19] Having a website used to set a business apart. Now, Levesque says, people are surprised when they reach a live human on a customer service call.
    • [05:27] Two photos of his sons taken 7 years apart, a $70 million deal that collapsed at the last minute, and a summer spent living in a tent on a Vermont farm.
    • [09:45] His “touch earth before touching a screen” routine: walk outside barefoot, put your feet on bare ground and take one deep breath.
    • [12:57] The morning he read an email sent under his name, hated it and slammed his laptop shut. That led to “The Embarrassing Confession” and his comparison of freshly squeezed orange juice to the canned kind.
    • [16:39] A painting bought for about $10,000 sold for $450 million after it was attributed to Leonardo da Vinci. Levesque ties that story to Steinway’s documentary and to the time-lapse video he made of hand-illustrating his book.

    Memorable Quotes

    • What doesn’t scale for you also will not scale for your competitor. And therein lies the competitive advantage. Doing the things that your competitor will not be willing to do.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “It’s not about being anti AI or being pro AI, it’s about finding the right places to put AI into your business.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “What the world is craving is what I describe as the freshly squeezed version of orange juice that you get at Sunday brunch in a world where everybody else is serving the watered-down stuff that comes in a can.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “When you combine those two simple practices, touch earth before you touch screen, and create before you consume, it’ll shift your day, which will shift your week, which will shift your month, which will shift your year.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “For those of us who are knowledge workers, for those of us who spend time in front of a computer, we have to find an outlet that reconnects us to our body, that reconnects us to the analog, that reconnects us to the physical world.” – Ryan Levesque

    Resources

    John Jantsch (00:01.276)

    So AI can write your emails, run your ads, clone the sound of your voice, even. But at least for now, it cannot fake a hug, a hand-tied knot, or the crack in your voice on a hard sales call. The entrepreneurs with the biggest edge over the next decade are the ones who find what technology can’t touch and build their whole business around it. Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch. My guest today is Ryan Levesque. He is a seven-time

    Inc. 500 CEO who’s built and exited two companies worth more than $100 million combined. He’s the number one national best-selling author of Ask, named Inc.’s marketing book of the year and founder of the Ask Method. His new book we’re going to talk about today, Return to Real, the last human advantage in an age of artificial everything, argues the same thing your body and spirit are starving for is exactly what your market will pay a premium for. So, Ryan, welcome to the show.

    Ryan Levesque (00:59.832)

    John, it’s great to be here and it’s great to reconnect.

    John Jantsch (01:02.896)

    Yeah, so I would suggest that this is a different book than Ask. however, I I’ve gotta believe that there’s a thread of your work in Ask and the work you did with the company that sort of informs this book, but I’ll let you speak to that if that’s accurate at all.

    Ryan Levesque (01:22.018)

    Yeah, you know, great questions. My first book Ask was all about figuring out what your market wants and giving it to them. And and I think it I remain proud of that work to this day. It’s a methodology to listen to the voice of your customer and use that to inform your messaging, your marketing and your products and services, so on and so forth. But what that book failed to explain and explore is how to listen to the most important voice of them all.

    Which is what I describe as the voice inside or the contrarian voice of your heart. And I think the age that we live in here today is one where, and there’s tremendous evidence to suggest this, we are drowning in artificial everything, from the food we eat to the content we consume. And Adam Maseri of Instagram, I think said it best when he said, We spent the last decade trying to figure out what makes something perfect. We’re gonna spend the next decade figuring out what makes something real.

    John Jantsch (02:20.08)

    Yeah. So yeah, you know, I I think the entrepreneurial world though is sort of naturally I I don’t want to say it’s against that, but it’s you can eat it’s easy to see why people get pulled in directions. It’s like, there’s an opportunity over here. I you know, AI is a great example. you know, I can make my agency an AI agency so that I can go in and like take advantage of what’s there, even if it’s not in your heart. I mean, how do you guard against that?

    Ryan Levesque (02:20.908)

    And I that’s what the world is craving is real.

    Ryan Levesque (02:47.32)

    Well, what I would say is this, look, I am not like I’m not one of these AI, anti-AI you know, apostles. I use AI on a daily basis. We use AI in my company. I I think the the truth is in the tension, the devil’s in the details. And I’ll give you a few examples. So I think one of the biggest mistakes that people make with AI is they use AI to abdicate parts of their business that touch the customer.

    John Jantsch (02:52.241)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (03:12.07)

    Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (03:12.896)

    Instead, what we should be doing is thinking about the proverbial back office of our business, the parts that are furthest away from what touches the customer, and use AI to automate those pieces of the business. Not to automate the email sequence that we send to our customers or to write the social media posts that’s the first point of contact with our brand, or to use AI to replicate your voice and create some sort of AI avatar that you’re trying to pass off as you, but the reality is it’s just a machine.

    And when someone figures that out, they feel foolish for having been humiliated and they associate that with your brand forevermore. So I think it’s not about being anti AI or being pro AI, it’s about finding the right places to put AI into your business.

    John Jantsch (03:57.201)

    Yeah, it’s funny. I th I think you know, a lot of people are starting to say, you know, the businesses are gonna win are the ones that are more human or that put that human element out there. And I think that there’s a double-edged sword on that, in that I think some people are saying, okay, I’ll put my human avatar out there. And I think you actually get whacked twice for that. It’s like you were trying to be human and you were actually less human, you know, for doing that. Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (04:19.626)

    It’s the hypocrisy of humanization. It’s a hypocrisy of humanization. It’s people are giving lip service to it, but they’re not willing to do the things that it really means. Like when you first came into the business world, you probably remember an era where having a website was a new and novel thing. Like it was a competitive advantage to be on the internet. That was a big deal. Now everybody’s on the internet. The pendulum is swung in the opposite direction. Now it’s actually a big deal. When you pick up the phone and call customer service,

    John Jantsch (04:26.343)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (04:35.909)

    yeah.

    John Jantsch (04:39.548)

    Yeah. Yep.

    Ryan Levesque (04:48.652)

    And you actually get an English speaking human being who picks up the phone on the other side and you say, my gosh, like are you, are you AI? Are you a robot? Are you an automated message? No, I’m a real human being. That is where the zig has become the zag.

    John Jantsch (05:04.668)

    So you I I think I read it with the figure was seventy million dollars, a deal to sell your company fell apart. not long after that, you moved to where I assume you are sitting today on the two hundred year old farm in Vermont. w w are those two connected? Like did you have a moment where you said, I gotta get out of here, I gotta point at something different.

    Ryan Levesque (05:11.086)

    Sure. Yep.

    Ryan Levesque (05:27.916)

    Very much connected. So spent the a better part of a decade building and scaling a company. literally started it, you know, with a laptop and an internet connection, kitchen table story. Seven timing 5000, fastest growing company, and had this moment where I I looked at this photograph of my two boys, and at the time they were three and five years old, my sons, they were wearing rain boots, holding hands and a path ahead of me. The boots were way too big for them. And I just remembered to take a photo of that moment. And

    Fast forward seven years later, and I had a similar experience where my two boys were walking down the path. They’re much further ahead of me now. They were not holding hands. and they were teenagers at the time. And it was like a heartbeat between those two moments. And I recognized that I had maybe just a few years left with my two boys at home before they grew up and they were gone. And I kind of asked myself, after we’d tried to sell the company twice, took the company to market, had a deal.

    John Jantsch (06:05.138)

    Yes.

    Ryan Levesque (06:27.306)

    Ended at the 11th hour, took the company to market again, had a $70 million offer, collapsed at the last minute. do I want to spend another decade or even half decade in this mode? Or do I want to maybe reoptimize my life for something else? And and the answer was very clear. I want to suck the marrow out of this season of life while my boys are at home. And and on that journey, when my boys were away at summer camp one summer, I decided to do something that was pulling at my heart. And I decided to.

    take take some time to live and and work on a farm in the Mad River Valley of Vermont, literally living in a tent, bathing in a pond, learning how to raise and grow food with my own hands. And John, it was on that farm that I had this awakening that I just felt like in this next chapter of life, this is where I was meant to be. And then that sparked a whole grand adventure that led to me exiting the company and starting this farm and moving my family and

    Crazy, crazy family adventure.

    John Jantsch (07:27.539)

    So I’m getting a throw vibe all of a sudden.

    Ryan Levesque (07:31.662)

    Throw is is referenced in the book. Throw is one of my heroes as a young man and and as a as a much older man today.

    John Jantsch (07:40.455)

    Yeah. So one of the things you write about is contrarian shifts. And the first thing is that the best things in life don’t scale. That sort of runs counter to like traditional business advice. I think a lot of people get that. I don’t think many people would actually argue, but like the whole deal is to scale, right? I mean, so how do you balance that?

    Ryan Levesque (07:57.987)

    Yeah. Well, look, I I think it’s again, truth is in the tension. I think there’s a modern exception exception with scale. Whenever I bring up the ideas behind return to to real, the inevitable objection that comes up is but does it scale? How do you scale that? And the the argument that I make is look, the best things in life don’t scale. You know, a hug with your kid, a sunset with your sweetheart, these things don’t scale. but we somehow think that the rules in business are immune to that universal truth.

    John Jantsch (08:02.641)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (08:13.799)

    This is

    Ryan Levesque (08:27.746)

    So the question isn’t do I create a business that doesn’t scale? It’s what are the parts of my business do I do in spite of the fact that they don’t scale? Because what doesn’t scale for you also will not scale for your competitor. And therein lies the competitive advantage. Doing the things that your competitor will not be willing to do. It’s sending a personal voice memo to every new customer, yourself.

    Not using some AI, 11 lab software or an assistant that’s doing it for you. It’s you. It’s it’s handwriting a welcome note to everyone who becomes a client. It’s not doing all the things, but it’s picking and choosing these moments that demonstrate to your market, to your customers, to your clients that wow, you really care. You really, really care about who it is that you’re serving.

    John Jantsch (09:24.006)

    So if there’s a listener out there that’s saying, look, I I’m I’ve got this business and I’m feeling the tension and I want to make some change, but I’m kind of shackled with a few things, right. I can’t just like, you know, take off tomorrow and and ch blow up everything. So what’s a small real version of, you know, returning to real that somebody could make?

    Ryan Levesque (09:32.59)

    Mm-hmm.

    Ryan Levesque (09:45.987)

    Yeah, so I’ll give a personal one and then I’ll give a a business one. So on a on a personal level, there’s a practice that I learned to adopt from a colleague of mine. And it’s the simplest thing in the world, and it’s something that I would encourage you to try yourself. The idea is this when you wake up in the morning, first thing, touch earth before touching a screen.

    So instead of doing what you normally do, where you check your phone, you check your messages, you check your email, whatever, put your device far away from you, walk outside your front door, find the first piece of actual bare earth, not pavement, not concrete, but grass or dirt or something in front of you. Take your shoes off, your socks off. And whatever time you wake up, I don’t care how cold it is, I do this in the winter in Vermont, you step outside, bare feet, you touch the ground just for a moment, take the deepest breath that you can, and just remind yourself that you are.

    A biophysical being in a biophysical world. And before you get sucked into dashboards and dopamine loops and all the demands of the day, that you are human and you’re deeply connected to the natural world. It’s a super small thing, like it’ll only take you 30 seconds to do this. But what it does is it sets the tone for the rest of the day. Like you become calmer, you become kinder, you take all the fires that show up in your business in stride, you put things in perspective in a way that’s sort of unlike anything else.

    so that’s a super simple personal move. Professionally.

    John Jantsch (11:08.658)

    Well, and that that that could actually be enough for some people. Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (11:12.122)

    And that absolutely can be enough. That can be the bite-sized version of Return to Real to just before I get sucked into the digital vortex of the day and social media scrolling and all the things. It’s like I’ve got this moment and it’s 30 seconds. I do it at at sunrise. Or I stare off into the sunrise in the mountains in the distance on our farm. And I just take this moment. And for me, it’s like it just sets the tone for the whole day. so that’s the personal side. Professional side, I would combine that.

    With a principle that I describe in the book as create before you consume. There is a tendency, first thing in the morning, that we get into consumption mode. We open up our emails and we consume the emails that are sent our way. Or we go on social media and we read the headlines. We actually are consuming what’s showing up in our world. I would challenge you to use that moment in the day when the chalkboard in your brain is clean. There’s nothing on it. It’s just a clean slate. You use those precious moments to create.

    For me, I use that time to write email. I will write an email to my audience with a clear head based on what it is that I’m thinking, what’s showing up in my heart, the ideas that I’m thinking about, how it relates to my market, but I do it with a clear mind. And when you combine those two simple practices, touch earth before you touch screen, and create before you consume, it’ll shift your day, which will shift your week, which will shift your month, which will shift your year.

    John Jantsch (12:38.546)

    Okay, this is a perfect segue to a questi or a a a a thing that you have talked about. you told your own list that team of writers had ghostwritten your content under your name for seven na years.

    What did it feel like to send that confession emailed to your list?

    Ryan Levesque (12:57.15)

    Yeah.

    it was not easy. because I felt like in some ways, even though this is standard practice in the industry, you have a team of writers. If you’re the CEO of your company, it’s not uncommon that you’ve got a team of writers that are writing content in your name, they’re ghostwriting that content, and they’re signing that content with your name. And for me, it became this sort of this death by a thousand paper cuts, where at first I was reviewing every email that went out with by my name.

    And then of course there’s a time where things get a little too busy and you’re like, all right, it’s probably fine. And then you get into the habit of you don’t even review anything. And then one day I remember waking up and I opened up my laptop and I read an email that we sent out that was in it was in it was we positioned it as it was something that I wrote and it came from me. And I was so disgusted with what we put up, I slammed the laptop shut. And I think for me that was the breaking point where I said, no more, this is not happening.

    and so on a whim, I wrote this email. I titled it The Embarrassing Confession and basically said what you described. I have an embarrassing confession to make. this may come as a shock, but every single email that you have read with my name signed to it has not actually been written by me, but it’s been written by a team of writers and more recently written by AI. and this has been true for the last seven years. I’m not proud of this fact, but it’s the truth. And I basically said, what I’ve realized is that

    What the world is craving is what I describe as the freshly squeezed version of orange juice that you get at Sunday brunch in a world where everybody else is serving the watered-down stuff that comes in a can. Can you feel the difference between what’s real and what’s not? Can you feel that this was written by a real human being with a real beating heart? Can you feel it? And when I sent that email out, I had no idea what was gonna happen, John. I got

    Ryan Levesque (14:51.38)

    More response from that email than anything that I’d sent in probably months, as long as I can remember. And it was the full range. Some people applauded it. Good for you. That’s amazing. I want to do this. some people used it as a way to blackmail me, you know. Hey, well, if that’s the case, then I want a refund for everything that I’ve ever bought, you know, years and years into the past, like crazy things like that. People said some things that I’m not gonna repeat out loud.

    You know, but way the way I describe it is people will confuse vulnerability with weakness and they will weaponize shame and guilt to coerce you to crumble. They will try to get you to fold. Oftentimes because it’s because it’s something that they’re dealing with internally themselves.

    John Jantsch (15:37.658)

    I was gonna I was gonna say my mom used to always say, Well, that’s probably more their problem than yours.

    Ryan Levesque (15:42.683)

    It’s very perceptive. When you’re in that moment, though, it is still hard when you’re people are telling you to crawl in a hole and die for what it is that you’re doing. but I’ll tell you, it was the mo the most liberating thing that I’ve done. And this was all almost two and a half years ago. And every single week since then, without missing a single week, I’ve personally written by hand myself an email, often two to four thousand words, deeply researched, very transparent, that’s come directly from me.

    And I’ve had more opportunity come from doing just that one thing than anything else I’ve done in my business in the last 20 years.

    John Jantsch (16:19.899)

    So back back to the book. the book’s core claim is that the market will pay a premium for real. but I can hear a lot of business owners say, Okay, that’s great. What’s the mechanism? Like, you know, real’s a word that everybody banters around, but like what’s the mechanism? You know, is it trust? Is it scarcity? Is it something else?

    Ryan Levesque (16:39.202)

    Yeah, there are a few different dimensions at play. And we’ve got look, we’ve got a short amount of time, and I want to try to unpack this as much as I can. I’ll give you one thing to really anchor around. It’s a concept that I describe in the book as the provenance premium. So provenance is a fancy word that comes from the art world. It basically is a way to trace back a piece of work to the creator of that work. And there’s a story I tell in the book about a painting called Salvador Mundi, which was purchased at an estate sale by a consortium of art dealers for something like $10,000.

    They did a bunch of research on the piece of art and found out that it was actually created by Leonardo da Vinci. And a few years later, they brought it to auction at Christie’s. And the same piece of art that they bought for $10,000 from an anonymous artist, once it was attributed to Leonardo da Vinci, sold for $450 million. And I that’s an extreme example, but it illustrates the point and hopefully is a memorable story that you’ll remember after this conversation.

    That when you can attribute the work that you’re doing to a real life that’s actually been lived and work that’s gone into it, it elevates the value of that work. It’s in part the reason why Steinway pianos sell for the what they sell for. Because Steinway has done a fantastic job, not only creating a great product, but documenting. There’s a whole documentary that Steinway put out where you can see what goes into making the piano. And you think, well, gosh, it’s, it’s, it’s, of course it’s worth that.

    It’s why people will pay a premium for food that’s raised by actual farmers down the road as opposed to buying it at the grocery store. Because they know the farmers, they know the farm, they know the story behind it. So the practical move here for all of us, no matter what type of work you’re in, if you’re in a white-collar profession, a blue collar profession, if you do work with your hands, if you do work with your mind, is to build in public, to document your process, to document your thinking about what you’re actually thinking about. Because people care not just about the what that it is that you’re selling.

    They care about the how in terms of how it’s made and the who. Who is the person behind that? And by telling the right story and sharing this, divulging this, taking people behind the scenes, people will pay a premium for that thing. In my book, I’ll give you one last example. I decided to hand illustrate every illustration inside the book. And I know that some people were gonna doubt that I actually hand illustrated the book. And here’s just a like a page inside the book with some of the quotes.

    John Jantsch (19:01.527)

    Mm. Beautiful.

    Ryan Levesque (19:02.732)

    And so what I did is I put a camera over my desk and I did a time-lapse video of drawing every illustration by hand. When people see that, it just is a proxy, an indicator that care and love and attention went into the making of this thing. And just that data point alone, doesn’t it make you believe that wow, a lot of effort went into creating this? And people value that.

    John Jantsch (19:10.854)

    Yes.

    Ryan Levesque (19:29.518)

    So when people see the provenance where something comes from, they will pay a premium for that product. So ask yourself, how can you document your process? How can you take people behind the scenes what it is that you do? How can you show the parts that nobody else, no other competitor of yours, shows how the sausage is made, so to speak? So people see the value in what it is that they’re actually getting.

    John Jantsch (19:51.826)

    All right, I’ve got one final question. This one’s more of a personal interest question. And this doesn’t really show up in your book, but I suspect you have an opinion on this. How important do you believe it is, particularly for entrepreneurs that might spend eight, nine hours a day just on a computer, you know, in the digital world, you know, doing all the stuff that we do today in businesses? How important do you think it is for them to have an analog outlet to do something with their hands to

    you know, build furniture to whatever, play the guitar, whatever it is that that that is is more analog thought.

    Ryan Levesque (20:27.596)

    Yeah, it’s Rabbi Heschel has this line that if you work with your mind, Sabbath with your hands.

    John Jantsch (20:38.363)

    Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (20:39.852)

    And I think for those of us who are knowledge workers, for those of us who spend time in front of a computer, we have to find an outlet that reconnects us to our body, that reconnects us to the analog, that reconnects us to the physical world, because that’s exactly what we’re losing. as I write in the book, there are trillion dollar technology companies that will not stop until every moment of human attention has been consumed and monetized, including yours.

    John Jantsch (21:04.517)

    Yeah. Yeah, I I I marvel at the aggressiveness of Facebook to try to get me to come back to the platform. I mean it’s unbelievable. and it’s yeah, I’m glad they’re I’m glad they’re facing some some blowback. we’ll see we’ll see if it, you know, does anything or if they’ll find another way around that.

    Well, Ryan, I appreciate you taking a few moments to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. is there any place you’d invite people to connect you to connect with you or to certainly to find out more about Return to Real?

    Ryan Levesque (21:37.154)

    Yeah, the the best place to learn more about the book, Return to Real, is return to RealBook.com. when you go there, you’ll see all the different formats and cool bonuses that you get access to. And I’m excited to share this with the world. I think it’s an incredibly practical book for anybody who’s sort of been in this tension of how much of my business do I abdicate to AI? What do I keep real? How does this affect my personal life? How does this affect my kids?

    And how does this affect my business and the work that I’m putting out into the world?

    John Jantsch (22:12.721)

    Well we I look forward to depending upon when you’re listening to this, the book will be out and available everywhere. We we have ordered copies ourselves to give give to my team. Awesome. Well I appreciate you stopping by and hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road.

    Ryan Levesque (22:28.151)

    Awesome. Thanks, Sean.

  • Where AI Belongs in Your Business

    Where AI Belongs in Your Business written by Jordan E read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode: Overview This one’s back from the vault. AI tools keep piling up, so the question John Jantsch and Ryan Levesque take on here matters more now than when it first aired. Where should AI save you time, and where does a personal touch let you charge more? Levesque runs AI every […]

    Where AI Belongs in Your Business written by Jordan E read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode:

    Overview

    Ryan Levesque, founder of the ASK Method, smiling in a light blue plaid shirt on a navy background beside the Duct Tape Marketing logo. Episode: What Should You Automate With AI, and What Should Stay Human? featuring guest Ryan Levesque and host John Jantsch on the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast.

    This one’s back from the vault. AI tools keep piling up, so the question John Jantsch and Ryan Levesque take on here matters more now than when it first aired. Where should AI save you time, and where does a personal touch let you charge more?

    Levesque runs AI every day inside his own company. He explains how he decides what gets automated (the back office comes first) and what he won’t hand off. He and Jantsch also get into why work that doesn’t scale can set you apart and how letting customers see your process supports higher prices. Levesque also shares a 30-second morning habit that shapes the rest of his day.

    Running a consultancy, an agency or a growing business? You’ll walk away with ideas you can test this week.

    Guest Bio

    Ryan Levesque has built and exited 2 companies with a combined value of more than $100 million, and he’s made the Inc. 5000 list 7 times as CEO. He wrote Ask, a No. 1 national bestseller and Inc.’s marketing book of the year, and he founded the ASK Method. His latest book is Return to Real: The Last Human Advantage in an Age of Artificial Everything. In it he argues that the things our bodies and spirits are hungry for are the same things customers will pay a premium for.

    Key Takeaways

    • Point AI at the back office first, the work that sits furthest from your customer. The email sequences and social posts that make your first impression need a human voice.
    • Choose a few moments that won’t scale and handle them yourself. A voice memo to every new customer or a handwritten note to every new client shows a kind of care software can’t fake.
    • Show your work. Let customers see how things get made and who makes them. The story behind the work is part of what they pay for.
    • Make something before you scroll. Use the first minutes of your day, while your head is clear, to write or build before email and social media pull you in.
    • Publish your own thinking on a schedule. For nearly 2.5 years Levesque has sent a weekly email, often 2,000 to 4,000 words long. He credits it with bringing in more opportunity than anything else he’s done in 20 years of business.

    Great Moments

    • [04:19] Having a website used to set a business apart. Now, Levesque says, people are surprised when they reach a live human on a customer service call.
    • [05:27] Two photos of his sons taken 7 years apart, a $70 million deal that collapsed at the last minute, and a summer spent living in a tent on a Vermont farm.
    • [09:45] His “touch earth before touching a screen” routine: walk outside barefoot, put your feet on bare ground and take one deep breath.
    • [12:57] The morning he read an email sent under his name, hated it and slammed his laptop shut. That led to “The Embarrassing Confession” and his comparison of freshly squeezed orange juice to the canned kind.
    • [16:39] A painting bought for about $10,000 sold for $450 million after it was attributed to Leonardo da Vinci. Levesque ties that story to Steinway’s documentary and to the time-lapse video he made of hand-illustrating his book.

    Memorable Quotes

    • What doesn’t scale for you also will not scale for your competitor. And therein lies the competitive advantage. Doing the things that your competitor will not be willing to do.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “It’s not about being anti AI or being pro AI, it’s about finding the right places to put AI into your business.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “What the world is craving is what I describe as the freshly squeezed version of orange juice that you get at Sunday brunch in a world where everybody else is serving the watered-down stuff that comes in a can.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “When you combine those two simple practices, touch earth before you touch screen, and create before you consume, it’ll shift your day, which will shift your week, which will shift your month, which will shift your year.” – Ryan Levesque
    • “For those of us who are knowledge workers, for those of us who spend time in front of a computer, we have to find an outlet that reconnects us to our body, that reconnects us to the analog, that reconnects us to the physical world.” – Ryan Levesque

    Resources

    John Jantsch (00:01.276)

    So AI can write your emails, run your ads, clone the sound of your voice, even. But at least for now, it cannot fake a hug, a hand-tied knot, or the crack in your voice on a hard sales call. The entrepreneurs with the biggest edge over the next decade are the ones who find what technology can’t touch and build their whole business around it. Hello and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch. My guest today is Ryan Levesque. He is a seven-time

    Inc. 500 CEO who’s built and exited two companies worth more than $100 million combined. He’s the number one national best-selling author of Ask, named Inc.’s marketing book of the year and founder of the Ask Method. His new book we’re going to talk about today, Return to Real, the last human advantage in an age of artificial everything, argues the same thing your body and spirit are starving for is exactly what your market will pay a premium for. So, Ryan, welcome to the show.

    Ryan Levesque (00:59.832)

    John, it’s great to be here and it’s great to reconnect.

    John Jantsch (01:02.896)

    Yeah, so I would suggest that this is a different book than Ask. however, I I’ve gotta believe that there’s a thread of your work in Ask and the work you did with the company that sort of informs this book, but I’ll let you speak to that if that’s accurate at all.

    Ryan Levesque (01:22.018)

    Yeah, you know, great questions. My first book Ask was all about figuring out what your market wants and giving it to them. And and I think it I remain proud of that work to this day. It’s a methodology to listen to the voice of your customer and use that to inform your messaging, your marketing and your products and services, so on and so forth. But what that book failed to explain and explore is how to listen to the most important voice of them all.

    Which is what I describe as the voice inside or the contrarian voice of your heart. And I think the age that we live in here today is one where, and there’s tremendous evidence to suggest this, we are drowning in artificial everything, from the food we eat to the content we consume. And Adam Maseri of Instagram, I think said it best when he said, We spent the last decade trying to figure out what makes something perfect. We’re gonna spend the next decade figuring out what makes something real.

    John Jantsch (02:20.08)

    Yeah. So yeah, you know, I I think the entrepreneurial world though is sort of naturally I I don’t want to say it’s against that, but it’s you can eat it’s easy to see why people get pulled in directions. It’s like, there’s an opportunity over here. I you know, AI is a great example. you know, I can make my agency an AI agency so that I can go in and like take advantage of what’s there, even if it’s not in your heart. I mean, how do you guard against that?

    Ryan Levesque (02:20.908)

    And I that’s what the world is craving is real.

    Ryan Levesque (02:47.32)

    Well, what I would say is this, look, I am not like I’m not one of these AI, anti-AI you know, apostles. I use AI on a daily basis. We use AI in my company. I I think the the truth is in the tension, the devil’s in the details. And I’ll give you a few examples. So I think one of the biggest mistakes that people make with AI is they use AI to abdicate parts of their business that touch the customer.

    John Jantsch (02:52.241)

    Yeah, yeah.

    John Jantsch (03:12.07)

    Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (03:12.896)

    Instead, what we should be doing is thinking about the proverbial back office of our business, the parts that are furthest away from what touches the customer, and use AI to automate those pieces of the business. Not to automate the email sequence that we send to our customers or to write the social media posts that’s the first point of contact with our brand, or to use AI to replicate your voice and create some sort of AI avatar that you’re trying to pass off as you, but the reality is it’s just a machine.

    And when someone figures that out, they feel foolish for having been humiliated and they associate that with your brand forevermore. So I think it’s not about being anti AI or being pro AI, it’s about finding the right places to put AI into your business.

    John Jantsch (03:57.201)

    Yeah, it’s funny. I th I think you know, a lot of people are starting to say, you know, the businesses are gonna win are the ones that are more human or that put that human element out there. And I think that there’s a double-edged sword on that, in that I think some people are saying, okay, I’ll put my human avatar out there. And I think you actually get whacked twice for that. It’s like you were trying to be human and you were actually less human, you know, for doing that. Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (04:19.626)

    It’s the hypocrisy of humanization. It’s a hypocrisy of humanization. It’s people are giving lip service to it, but they’re not willing to do the things that it really means. Like when you first came into the business world, you probably remember an era where having a website was a new and novel thing. Like it was a competitive advantage to be on the internet. That was a big deal. Now everybody’s on the internet. The pendulum is swung in the opposite direction. Now it’s actually a big deal. When you pick up the phone and call customer service,

    John Jantsch (04:26.343)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (04:35.909)

    yeah.

    John Jantsch (04:39.548)

    Yeah. Yep.

    Ryan Levesque (04:48.652)

    And you actually get an English speaking human being who picks up the phone on the other side and you say, my gosh, like are you, are you AI? Are you a robot? Are you an automated message? No, I’m a real human being. That is where the zig has become the zag.

    John Jantsch (05:04.668)

    So you I I think I read it with the figure was seventy million dollars, a deal to sell your company fell apart. not long after that, you moved to where I assume you are sitting today on the two hundred year old farm in Vermont. w w are those two connected? Like did you have a moment where you said, I gotta get out of here, I gotta point at something different.

    Ryan Levesque (05:11.086)

    Sure. Yep.

    Ryan Levesque (05:27.916)

    Very much connected. So spent the a better part of a decade building and scaling a company. literally started it, you know, with a laptop and an internet connection, kitchen table story. Seven timing 5000, fastest growing company, and had this moment where I I looked at this photograph of my two boys, and at the time they were three and five years old, my sons, they were wearing rain boots, holding hands and a path ahead of me. The boots were way too big for them. And I just remembered to take a photo of that moment. And

    Fast forward seven years later, and I had a similar experience where my two boys were walking down the path. They’re much further ahead of me now. They were not holding hands. and they were teenagers at the time. And it was like a heartbeat between those two moments. And I recognized that I had maybe just a few years left with my two boys at home before they grew up and they were gone. And I kind of asked myself, after we’d tried to sell the company twice, took the company to market, had a deal.

    John Jantsch (06:05.138)

    Yes.

    Ryan Levesque (06:27.306)

    Ended at the 11th hour, took the company to market again, had a $70 million offer, collapsed at the last minute. do I want to spend another decade or even half decade in this mode? Or do I want to maybe reoptimize my life for something else? And and the answer was very clear. I want to suck the marrow out of this season of life while my boys are at home. And and on that journey, when my boys were away at summer camp one summer, I decided to do something that was pulling at my heart. And I decided to.

    take take some time to live and and work on a farm in the Mad River Valley of Vermont, literally living in a tent, bathing in a pond, learning how to raise and grow food with my own hands. And John, it was on that farm that I had this awakening that I just felt like in this next chapter of life, this is where I was meant to be. And then that sparked a whole grand adventure that led to me exiting the company and starting this farm and moving my family and

    Crazy, crazy family adventure.

    John Jantsch (07:27.539)

    So I’m getting a throw vibe all of a sudden.

    Ryan Levesque (07:31.662)

    Throw is is referenced in the book. Throw is one of my heroes as a young man and and as a as a much older man today.

    John Jantsch (07:40.455)

    Yeah. So one of the things you write about is contrarian shifts. And the first thing is that the best things in life don’t scale. That sort of runs counter to like traditional business advice. I think a lot of people get that. I don’t think many people would actually argue, but like the whole deal is to scale, right? I mean, so how do you balance that?

    Ryan Levesque (07:57.987)

    Yeah. Well, look, I I think it’s again, truth is in the tension. I think there’s a modern exception exception with scale. Whenever I bring up the ideas behind return to to real, the inevitable objection that comes up is but does it scale? How do you scale that? And the the argument that I make is look, the best things in life don’t scale. You know, a hug with your kid, a sunset with your sweetheart, these things don’t scale. but we somehow think that the rules in business are immune to that universal truth.

    John Jantsch (08:02.641)

    Yeah.

    John Jantsch (08:13.799)

    This is

    Ryan Levesque (08:27.746)

    So the question isn’t do I create a business that doesn’t scale? It’s what are the parts of my business do I do in spite of the fact that they don’t scale? Because what doesn’t scale for you also will not scale for your competitor. And therein lies the competitive advantage. Doing the things that your competitor will not be willing to do. It’s sending a personal voice memo to every new customer, yourself.

    Not using some AI, 11 lab software or an assistant that’s doing it for you. It’s you. It’s it’s handwriting a welcome note to everyone who becomes a client. It’s not doing all the things, but it’s picking and choosing these moments that demonstrate to your market, to your customers, to your clients that wow, you really care. You really, really care about who it is that you’re serving.

    John Jantsch (09:24.006)

    So if there’s a listener out there that’s saying, look, I I’m I’ve got this business and I’m feeling the tension and I want to make some change, but I’m kind of shackled with a few things, right. I can’t just like, you know, take off tomorrow and and ch blow up everything. So what’s a small real version of, you know, returning to real that somebody could make?

    Ryan Levesque (09:32.59)

    Mm-hmm.

    Ryan Levesque (09:45.987)

    Yeah, so I’ll give a personal one and then I’ll give a a business one. So on a on a personal level, there’s a practice that I learned to adopt from a colleague of mine. And it’s the simplest thing in the world, and it’s something that I would encourage you to try yourself. The idea is this when you wake up in the morning, first thing, touch earth before touching a screen.

    So instead of doing what you normally do, where you check your phone, you check your messages, you check your email, whatever, put your device far away from you, walk outside your front door, find the first piece of actual bare earth, not pavement, not concrete, but grass or dirt or something in front of you. Take your shoes off, your socks off. And whatever time you wake up, I don’t care how cold it is, I do this in the winter in Vermont, you step outside, bare feet, you touch the ground just for a moment, take the deepest breath that you can, and just remind yourself that you are.

    A biophysical being in a biophysical world. And before you get sucked into dashboards and dopamine loops and all the demands of the day, that you are human and you’re deeply connected to the natural world. It’s a super small thing, like it’ll only take you 30 seconds to do this. But what it does is it sets the tone for the rest of the day. Like you become calmer, you become kinder, you take all the fires that show up in your business in stride, you put things in perspective in a way that’s sort of unlike anything else.

    so that’s a super simple personal move. Professionally.

    John Jantsch (11:08.658)

    Well, and that that that could actually be enough for some people. Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (11:12.122)

    And that absolutely can be enough. That can be the bite-sized version of Return to Real to just before I get sucked into the digital vortex of the day and social media scrolling and all the things. It’s like I’ve got this moment and it’s 30 seconds. I do it at at sunrise. Or I stare off into the sunrise in the mountains in the distance on our farm. And I just take this moment. And for me, it’s like it just sets the tone for the whole day. so that’s the personal side. Professional side, I would combine that.

    With a principle that I describe in the book as create before you consume. There is a tendency, first thing in the morning, that we get into consumption mode. We open up our emails and we consume the emails that are sent our way. Or we go on social media and we read the headlines. We actually are consuming what’s showing up in our world. I would challenge you to use that moment in the day when the chalkboard in your brain is clean. There’s nothing on it. It’s just a clean slate. You use those precious moments to create.

    For me, I use that time to write email. I will write an email to my audience with a clear head based on what it is that I’m thinking, what’s showing up in my heart, the ideas that I’m thinking about, how it relates to my market, but I do it with a clear mind. And when you combine those two simple practices, touch earth before you touch screen, and create before you consume, it’ll shift your day, which will shift your week, which will shift your month, which will shift your year.

    John Jantsch (12:38.546)

    Okay, this is a perfect segue to a questi or a a a a thing that you have talked about. you told your own list that team of writers had ghostwritten your content under your name for seven na years.

    What did it feel like to send that confession emailed to your list?

    Ryan Levesque (12:57.15)

    Yeah.

    it was not easy. because I felt like in some ways, even though this is standard practice in the industry, you have a team of writers. If you’re the CEO of your company, it’s not uncommon that you’ve got a team of writers that are writing content in your name, they’re ghostwriting that content, and they’re signing that content with your name. And for me, it became this sort of this death by a thousand paper cuts, where at first I was reviewing every email that went out with by my name.

    And then of course there’s a time where things get a little too busy and you’re like, all right, it’s probably fine. And then you get into the habit of you don’t even review anything. And then one day I remember waking up and I opened up my laptop and I read an email that we sent out that was in it was in it was we positioned it as it was something that I wrote and it came from me. And I was so disgusted with what we put up, I slammed the laptop shut. And I think for me that was the breaking point where I said, no more, this is not happening.

    and so on a whim, I wrote this email. I titled it The Embarrassing Confession and basically said what you described. I have an embarrassing confession to make. this may come as a shock, but every single email that you have read with my name signed to it has not actually been written by me, but it’s been written by a team of writers and more recently written by AI. and this has been true for the last seven years. I’m not proud of this fact, but it’s the truth. And I basically said, what I’ve realized is that

    What the world is craving is what I describe as the freshly squeezed version of orange juice that you get at Sunday brunch in a world where everybody else is serving the watered-down stuff that comes in a can. Can you feel the difference between what’s real and what’s not? Can you feel that this was written by a real human being with a real beating heart? Can you feel it? And when I sent that email out, I had no idea what was gonna happen, John. I got

    Ryan Levesque (14:51.38)

    More response from that email than anything that I’d sent in probably months, as long as I can remember. And it was the full range. Some people applauded it. Good for you. That’s amazing. I want to do this. some people used it as a way to blackmail me, you know. Hey, well, if that’s the case, then I want a refund for everything that I’ve ever bought, you know, years and years into the past, like crazy things like that. People said some things that I’m not gonna repeat out loud.

    You know, but way the way I describe it is people will confuse vulnerability with weakness and they will weaponize shame and guilt to coerce you to crumble. They will try to get you to fold. Oftentimes because it’s because it’s something that they’re dealing with internally themselves.

    John Jantsch (15:37.658)

    I was gonna I was gonna say my mom used to always say, Well, that’s probably more their problem than yours.

    Ryan Levesque (15:42.683)

    It’s very perceptive. When you’re in that moment, though, it is still hard when you’re people are telling you to crawl in a hole and die for what it is that you’re doing. but I’ll tell you, it was the mo the most liberating thing that I’ve done. And this was all almost two and a half years ago. And every single week since then, without missing a single week, I’ve personally written by hand myself an email, often two to four thousand words, deeply researched, very transparent, that’s come directly from me.

    And I’ve had more opportunity come from doing just that one thing than anything else I’ve done in my business in the last 20 years.

    John Jantsch (16:19.899)

    So back back to the book. the book’s core claim is that the market will pay a premium for real. but I can hear a lot of business owners say, Okay, that’s great. What’s the mechanism? Like, you know, real’s a word that everybody banters around, but like what’s the mechanism? You know, is it trust? Is it scarcity? Is it something else?

    Ryan Levesque (16:39.202)

    Yeah, there are a few different dimensions at play. And we’ve got look, we’ve got a short amount of time, and I want to try to unpack this as much as I can. I’ll give you one thing to really anchor around. It’s a concept that I describe in the book as the provenance premium. So provenance is a fancy word that comes from the art world. It basically is a way to trace back a piece of work to the creator of that work. And there’s a story I tell in the book about a painting called Salvador Mundi, which was purchased at an estate sale by a consortium of art dealers for something like $10,000.

    They did a bunch of research on the piece of art and found out that it was actually created by Leonardo da Vinci. And a few years later, they brought it to auction at Christie’s. And the same piece of art that they bought for $10,000 from an anonymous artist, once it was attributed to Leonardo da Vinci, sold for $450 million. And I that’s an extreme example, but it illustrates the point and hopefully is a memorable story that you’ll remember after this conversation.

    That when you can attribute the work that you’re doing to a real life that’s actually been lived and work that’s gone into it, it elevates the value of that work. It’s in part the reason why Steinway pianos sell for the what they sell for. Because Steinway has done a fantastic job, not only creating a great product, but documenting. There’s a whole documentary that Steinway put out where you can see what goes into making the piano. And you think, well, gosh, it’s, it’s, it’s, of course it’s worth that.

    It’s why people will pay a premium for food that’s raised by actual farmers down the road as opposed to buying it at the grocery store. Because they know the farmers, they know the farm, they know the story behind it. So the practical move here for all of us, no matter what type of work you’re in, if you’re in a white-collar profession, a blue collar profession, if you do work with your hands, if you do work with your mind, is to build in public, to document your process, to document your thinking about what you’re actually thinking about. Because people care not just about the what that it is that you’re selling.

    They care about the how in terms of how it’s made and the who. Who is the person behind that? And by telling the right story and sharing this, divulging this, taking people behind the scenes, people will pay a premium for that thing. In my book, I’ll give you one last example. I decided to hand illustrate every illustration inside the book. And I know that some people were gonna doubt that I actually hand illustrated the book. And here’s just a like a page inside the book with some of the quotes.

    John Jantsch (19:01.527)

    Mm. Beautiful.

    Ryan Levesque (19:02.732)

    And so what I did is I put a camera over my desk and I did a time-lapse video of drawing every illustration by hand. When people see that, it just is a proxy, an indicator that care and love and attention went into the making of this thing. And just that data point alone, doesn’t it make you believe that wow, a lot of effort went into creating this? And people value that.

    John Jantsch (19:10.854)

    Yes.

    Ryan Levesque (19:29.518)

    So when people see the provenance where something comes from, they will pay a premium for that product. So ask yourself, how can you document your process? How can you take people behind the scenes what it is that you do? How can you show the parts that nobody else, no other competitor of yours, shows how the sausage is made, so to speak? So people see the value in what it is that they’re actually getting.

    John Jantsch (19:51.826)

    All right, I’ve got one final question. This one’s more of a personal interest question. And this doesn’t really show up in your book, but I suspect you have an opinion on this. How important do you believe it is, particularly for entrepreneurs that might spend eight, nine hours a day just on a computer, you know, in the digital world, you know, doing all the stuff that we do today in businesses? How important do you think it is for them to have an analog outlet to do something with their hands to

    you know, build furniture to whatever, play the guitar, whatever it is that that that is is more analog thought.

    Ryan Levesque (20:27.596)

    Yeah, it’s Rabbi Heschel has this line that if you work with your mind, Sabbath with your hands.

    John Jantsch (20:38.363)

    Yeah.

    Ryan Levesque (20:39.852)

    And I think for those of us who are knowledge workers, for those of us who spend time in front of a computer, we have to find an outlet that reconnects us to our body, that reconnects us to the analog, that reconnects us to the physical world, because that’s exactly what we’re losing. as I write in the book, there are trillion dollar technology companies that will not stop until every moment of human attention has been consumed and monetized, including yours.

    John Jantsch (21:04.517)

    Yeah. Yeah, I I I marvel at the aggressiveness of Facebook to try to get me to come back to the platform. I mean it’s unbelievable. and it’s yeah, I’m glad they’re I’m glad they’re facing some some blowback. we’ll see we’ll see if it, you know, does anything or if they’ll find another way around that.

    Well, Ryan, I appreciate you taking a few moments to stop by the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. is there any place you’d invite people to connect you to connect with you or to certainly to find out more about Return to Real?

    Ryan Levesque (21:37.154)

    Yeah, the the best place to learn more about the book, Return to Real, is return to RealBook.com. when you go there, you’ll see all the different formats and cool bonuses that you get access to. And I’m excited to share this with the world. I think it’s an incredibly practical book for anybody who’s sort of been in this tension of how much of my business do I abdicate to AI? What do I keep real? How does this affect my personal life? How does this affect my kids?

    And how does this affect my business and the work that I’m putting out into the world?

    John Jantsch (22:12.721)

    Well we I look forward to depending upon when you’re listening to this, the book will be out and available everywhere. We we have ordered copies ourselves to give give to my team. Awesome. Well I appreciate you stopping by and hopefully we’ll run into you one of these days out there on the road.

    Ryan Levesque (22:28.151)

    Awesome. Thanks, Sean.

  • How to Protect Your Business Name With a Trademark

    How to Protect Your Business Name With a Trademark written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode Overview You found a great name, bought the domain, locked in the social handles and filed the LLC. It feels settled. But none of those steps gives you the legal right to use the name, and the conflict usually shows up after the logo is designed and the launch date is […]

    The Clearest Voice in the Room: How to Speak with Power and Intention at Work with Dr. Kristine Sickels written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the full episode:

     

    Overview

    Most of us have walked out of a meeting thinking, “I wish I’d said that.” Dr. Kristine Sickels has a name for it: the voice values gap. It’s the distance between what you believe and what actually comes out of your mouth. Left alone, that gap can quietly cost you promotions, clients, and credit for your own ideas.

    In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, John Jantsch talks with Sickels about her new book, The Clearest Voice in the Room. Sickels spent nearly 20 years in corporate marketing leadership. She shares the two 360 reviews that changed how she communicates, why “executive presence” so often rewards volume over substance, and how naming your values out loud gives your team a way to read you.

    They also walk through her VOICE framework (values, outcomes, identity, consistency, energy) and the shift from “spotlight speaker” to “lighthouse speaker.” This episode is for small business owners, marketers, and leaders who want to speak with more intention in meetings, sales conversations, and on stage.

    Guest bio

    Dr. Kristine Sickels spent nearly 20 years at Newell Brands. She rose to senior vice president of marketing over a portfolio worth more than $2 billion that included Rubbermaid, Crock-Pot, Calphalon, Mr. Coffee, and Oster. In 2010 she left corporate life and co-founded C-Sweet, a multimillion-dollar women-owned consulting firm.

    Sickels is part of the team at Mic Drop, an education company that helps women build keynotes, book paid speaking engagements, and grow their income and impact. She is the author of The Clearest Voice in the Room: How to Speak with Power and Intention at Work.

    Key takeaways

    • Start with values. Knowing what you stand for tells you what to say and which topics are worth speaking into.
    • Name your values out loud. When Sickels tells a team she values candor, optimism, and curiosity, they know how to read her feedback and her questions.
    • Set expectations so candor isn’t misread. When people know what’s coming, a direct critique reads as care for the work. Without that context, it can feel personal.
    • Decide the outcome before you walk in. Know whether you want a decision, feedback on a recommendation, or buy-in, and let that shape what you say.
    • Ask what “executive presence” means. If you get that feedback, ask for specifics. It might mean handling tough client questions or speaking confidently about risk.
    • Watch for the seven silencers. People often hold back because of what they’ve seen happen to others in their culture. A leader who punishes honest feedback ends up hearing none.
    • Remember why you’re in the room. Handing over the mic can feel kind. But you were hired for your expertise, and speaking up is part of the job.
    • Be a lighthouse speaker. Spotlight speakers worry about how they look. Lighthouse speakers focus on guiding the room through an idea or decision, and that focus eases a lot of the nerves.
    • Get your reps in. Waiting for the big moment means missing the everyday meetings where comfort gets built. Try different styles until one feels like you.
    • Your energy speaks first. Walking in hurried, distracted, or buried in your phone says plenty before you open your mouth.

    Great moments

    [00:01]: John opens with the hidden cost of never saying what you believe out loud

    [02:13]: Sickels shares the two 360 reviews that reshaped how she communicates

    [04:18]: The voice values gap, and that “I wish I’d said that” feeling

    [05:52]: Why company values on the wall don’t help when leaders haven’t defined their own

    [06:50]: An introduction to the seven silencers

    [07:59]: Naming your values to your team: optimism, curiosity, and candor

    [10:26]: The trouble with “executive presence” and the loudest voice in the room

    [12:21]: Why women often hand over the mic, and why they shouldn’t

    [13:15]: Spotlight speaker vs. lighthouse speaker

    [15:20]: The VOICE framework: values, outcomes, identity, consistency, energy

    [17:50]: Finding a speaking style that feels authentic

    [18:40]: Inside Mic Drop and how it helps women build paid speaking careers

    [20:11]: Where to find Sickels and her book

    Memorable quotes

    “I believe that candor is care.” – Dr. Kristine Sickels

    “It is not about being the loudest voice in the room. It is about being the clearest.” – Sickels

    “We are hired for our expertise. We are in the room for what we know.” – Sickels

    “Knowing what you stand for is going to help you know what to say.” – Sickels

    “If we walk into a room and we’re hurried or we’re distracted, we’ve already said a ton and we’ve said nothing.” – Sickels

    Resources

    • The Clearest Voice in the Room (book):
    • C-Sweet:
    • Mic Drop: micdropworkshop.com
    • Connect with Dr. Kristine Sickels on LinkedIn:
    • Connect with John Jantsch: john@ducttapemarketing.com
  • The Clearest Voice in the Room: How to Speak with Power and Intention at Work with Dr. Kristine Sickels

    The Clearest Voice in the Room: How to Speak with Power and Intention at Work with Dr. Kristine Sickels written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the full episode:   Overview Most of us have walked out of a meeting thinking, “I wish I’d said that.” Dr. Kristine Sickels has a name for it: the voice values gap. It’s the distance between what you believe and what actually comes out of your mouth. Left alone, that gap can quietly cost […]

    The Clearest Voice in the Room: How to Speak with Power and Intention at Work with Dr. Kristine Sickels written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the full episode:

     

    Overview

    Most of us have walked out of a meeting thinking, “I wish I’d said that.” Dr. Kristine Sickels has a name for it: the voice values gap. It’s the distance between what you believe and what actually comes out of your mouth. Left alone, that gap can quietly cost you promotions, clients, and credit for your own ideas.

    In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, John Jantsch talks with Sickels about her new book, The Clearest Voice in the Room. Sickels spent nearly 20 years in corporate marketing leadership. She shares the two 360 reviews that changed how she communicates, why “executive presence” so often rewards volume over substance, and how naming your values out loud gives your team a way to read you.

    They also walk through her VOICE framework (values, outcomes, identity, consistency, energy) and the shift from “spotlight speaker” to “lighthouse speaker.” This episode is for small business owners, marketers, and leaders who want to speak with more intention in meetings, sales conversations, and on stage.

    Guest bio

    Dr. Kristine Sickels spent nearly 20 years at Newell Brands. She rose to senior vice president of marketing over a portfolio worth more than $2 billion that included Rubbermaid, Crock-Pot, Calphalon, Mr. Coffee, and Oster. In 2010 she left corporate life and co-founded C-Sweet, a multimillion-dollar women-owned consulting firm.

    Sickels is part of the team at Mic Drop, an education company that helps women build keynotes, book paid speaking engagements, and grow their income and impact. She is the author of The Clearest Voice in the Room: How to Speak with Power and Intention at Work.

    Key takeaways

    • Start with values. Knowing what you stand for tells you what to say and which topics are worth speaking into.
    • Name your values out loud. When Sickels tells a team she values candor, optimism, and curiosity, they know how to read her feedback and her questions.
    • Set expectations so candor isn’t misread. When people know what’s coming, a direct critique reads as care for the work. Without that context, it can feel personal.
    • Decide the outcome before you walk in. Know whether you want a decision, feedback on a recommendation, or buy-in, and let that shape what you say.
    • Ask what “executive presence” means. If you get that feedback, ask for specifics. It might mean handling tough client questions or speaking confidently about risk.
    • Watch for the seven silencers. People often hold back because of what they’ve seen happen to others in their culture. A leader who punishes honest feedback ends up hearing none.
    • Remember why you’re in the room. Handing over the mic can feel kind. But you were hired for your expertise, and speaking up is part of the job.
    • Be a lighthouse speaker. Spotlight speakers worry about how they look. Lighthouse speakers focus on guiding the room through an idea or decision, and that focus eases a lot of the nerves.
    • Get your reps in. Waiting for the big moment means missing the everyday meetings where comfort gets built. Try different styles until one feels like you.
    • Your energy speaks first. Walking in hurried, distracted, or buried in your phone says plenty before you open your mouth.

    Great moments

    [00:01]: John opens with the hidden cost of never saying what you believe out loud

    [02:13]: Sickels shares the two 360 reviews that reshaped how she communicates

    [04:18]: The voice values gap, and that “I wish I’d said that” feeling

    [05:52]: Why company values on the wall don’t help when leaders haven’t defined their own

    [06:50]: An introduction to the seven silencers

    [07:59]: Naming your values to your team: optimism, curiosity, and candor

    [10:26]: The trouble with “executive presence” and the loudest voice in the room

    [12:21]: Why women often hand over the mic, and why they shouldn’t

    [13:15]: Spotlight speaker vs. lighthouse speaker

    [15:20]: The VOICE framework: values, outcomes, identity, consistency, energy

    [17:50]: Finding a speaking style that feels authentic

    [18:40]: Inside Mic Drop and how it helps women build paid speaking careers

    [20:11]: Where to find Sickels and her book

    Memorable quotes

    “I believe that candor is care.” – Dr. Kristine Sickels

    “It is not about being the loudest voice in the room. It is about being the clearest.” – Sickels

    “We are hired for our expertise. We are in the room for what we know.” – Sickels

    “Knowing what you stand for is going to help you know what to say.” – Sickels

    “If we walk into a room and we’re hurried or we’re distracted, we’ve already said a ton and we’ve said nothing.” – Sickels

    Resources

    • The Clearest Voice in the Room (book):
    • C-Sweet:
    • Mic Drop: micdropworkshop.com
    • Connect with Dr. Kristine Sickels on LinkedIn:
    • Connect with John Jantsch: john@ducttapemarketing.com
  • How to Build an AI-Native Business That Actually Saves Time

    How to Build an AI-Native Business That Actually Saves Time written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode Overview Most small businesses think they’re using AI the moment they open ChatGPT. That’s a tool habit. Building your marketing processes around AI is a business model, and the gap between the two shows up in your results long before anyone can explain why. In this episode of the Duct Tape […]

    How to Build an AI-Native Business That Actually Saves Time written by John Jantsch read more at Duct Tape Marketing

    Catch the Full Episode

    Overview

    Most small businesses think they’re using AI the moment they open ChatGPT. That’s a tool habit. Building your marketing processes around AI is a business model, and the gap between the two shows up in your results long before anyone can explain why.

    In this episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, John Jantsch talks with Jérémy Jarry, CMO of Bookipi, about what happened when he rebuilt his marketing team around AI over the past year. Jarry explains what AI native means in practice, why his team started with one person and one dreaded task, and how they learned to measure AI by hours saved and revenue earned.

    This conversation is for small business owners, marketers, and agency leaders who are using AI tools but haven’t seen the payoff yet. You’ll hear how to pick your first process, what human in the loop looks like day to day, when to scale AI back, and how to keep up with constant change without chasing every new model.

    Guest Bio

    Jérémy Jarry is the Chief Marketing Officer of Bookipi, an international SaaS platform that millions of small businesses use for invoicing, proposals, contracts, websites, and getting paid. Over the past year, he rebuilt Bookipi’s marketing team around AI from the ground up and wrote about the experience for Entrepreneur. His work centers on growth, go-to-market execution, and applying AI across marketing so lean teams can compete with much larger companies.

    Key Takeaways

    • Jarry defines AI native as redesigning a process from scratch with AI’s capabilities in mind. He describes it as a mindset change for the whole team.
    • Start with your calendar. Look for the work that eats the most time and the work your team dreads, then see where AI fits.
    • Prove it with one person first. Bookipi started by automating one marketer’s reporting, which freed that person to explain the numbers instead of gathering them.
    • The same thinking applies outside marketing. A plumber with an AI receptionist can keep fixing the leak while the next job gets booked.
    • In a Bookipi survey of more than 2,000 customers, the top reason for skipping AI was a knowledge gap. The team expected cost to top the list.
    • AI still needs your direction. A prompt like “write an email for John” goes nowhere until you define the topic and the outcome you want.
    • Give people time to adopt. Bookipi let slower adopters keep their old processes, and they came around after seeing teammates spend more time on creative work.
    • Human in the loop means real review steps. Bookipi feeds AI a central knowledge base for brand voice, and nothing launches until a person checks every asset.
    • Measure hours saved and revenue. Counting how many agents the team built each week told Bookipi very little.
    • Review time has to be shorter than build time. If checking AI’s work takes longer than doing it yourself, pull the process back and rethink it.

    Great Moments (Timestamps)

    • [00:02] – John on the difference between a tool habit and a business model
    • [01:11] – The moment Bookipi decided to rethink its marketing processes
    • [02:04] – What AI native means, and why Jarry calls it a buzzword worth defining
    • [04:12] – Where small teams should start: your calendar
    • [05:08] – Automated reporting and the plumber with an AI receptionist
    • [07:23] – The 2,000-customer survey and the real barrier to AI adoption
    • [10:44] – Where adoption stalled and how the team handled it
    • [12:43] – What human in the loop looks like at Bookipi
    • [14:46] – Measuring agents built versus hours saved
    • [16:35] – Keeping up with the pace of AI without chasing every tool
    • [17:55] – How Bookipi started with a tradie’s invoicing app

    Memorable Quotes

    “Most small businesses think they’re using AI the moment they open ChatGPT at their desk. And that’s a tool habit, not a business model.” – John Jantsch

    “Look at your calendar. Look at what is actually taking a lot of time. Look at what you don’t like doing and see if you can integrate AI within it.” – Jarry

    “I don’t know many marketers that like to create reports.” – Jarry

    “We need to make sure that the time that the human is actually going to spend to review the campaign is actually less than the time it would take them to actually create a campaign from scratch themselves.” – Jarry

    Resources

    • Bookipi:

     

    John Jantsch (00:02.021)

    So, you know, most small businesses think they’re using AI the moment they open Chat GPT at their desk. And that’s a tool habit, not a business model. The gap between the two shows up in the results long before anyone can explain why. Hello, and welcome to another episode of the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast. This is John Jantsch, and my guest today is Jeremy Jerry. He’s a chief marketing officer at Book.

    BookKeepy, a SaaS platform millions of small businesses use for invoicing and day-to-day admin. Over the past year, Jerry built or rebuilt his own marketing team at BookKeepy around AI from the ground up and wrote about what actually looked like for Entrepreneur Magazine. So, Jeremy, welcome to the show.

    Jeremy Jarry (00:51.086)

    Thank you, John. It’s a pleasure to to be with you today.

    John Jantsch (00:55.195)

    So you as I mentioned in your intro, you spent the last year rewiring your own marketing team around AI. wha what was the moment maybe that that that you kind of took that stand that hey, maybe more tools wasn’t the same thing as actually using AI?

    Jeremy Jarry (01:11.83)

    Yeah, so about a year and a half ago, we saw how AI was developing and all the possibilities that AI could provide to a marketing team. And like a lot of businesses, we started using Chat GPT Claude to proofread our emails, look at the different possibilities that we could use AI for. And we thought, what if we actually rethink

    how our processes are actually working and can we rewire completely our marketing team to become more AI native?

    John Jantsch (01:54.726)

    So let’s start with that term first off. I mean, what’s the like what’s the real difference between using AI tools and being AI native?

    Jeremy Jarry (02:04.332)

    Yes, so I think AI native is also a buzzword. So it is important for us to really define it. And internally we’ve had a lot of conversations about what it means and what we actually wanted from AI and how we could use AI to redefine the processes. So the way we see it is instead of just stacking AI tools.

    John Jantsch (02:09.285)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (02:32.226)

    And thinking, we’re using AI to its fullest. We thought we have some processes. What if today we were redesigning these processes from scratch and using all the capabilities that AI is providing to actually have an AI-native process? So it’s becoming a big difference for us as being a mindset change more than just.

    Adding AI to the workflows that we had.

    John Jantsch (03:04.773)

    So how do you get started on that? I’m I’m thinking that a lot of my listeners are four or five person shops. and so the idea of, hey, we barely have processes, certainly barely have them documented, and now you’re telling me I have to tear all down. I mean, how did you get started with that? Because especially a business that’s been around for a while, maybe that there’s a lot of things that they’ve done for years and they seem to work.

    But but you’re right, they were never designed with AI in mind. They’re they’re sort of AI sort of being inserted into them. So so how do you get started on that I that that process itself of of tearing things down and and starting over again?

    Jeremy Jarry (03:45.281)

    Yeah, so we at Book Epi consider ourselves as a small business. we do have a small marketing team. and so it’s definitely something that we’re looking for also our customers, our small business customers, where it’s not always easy to have all the capabilities within the organization to compete with large companies. And

    John Jantsch (03:50.469)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (04:12.994)

    The way I would look at it for a small business is look at your calendar. Look at what is actually taking a lot of time. Look at what you don’t like doing and see if you can integrate AI within it. For small teams like ours, the way we we saw it was it’s about people and it’s about making sure that people are actually embracing AI.

    the way we do and the way we would want them to do. And so the way we did it, we started with one individual within the team, and we wanted to show results. And we wanted to show that it’s actually giving more time to the marketer to be more creative, to be more strategic. I don’t know many marketers that like to create reports, for example. And this is where we started by.

    John Jantsch (05:04.699)

    Right.

    Jeremy Jarry (05:08.214)

    Automating and then adding AI to have better reporting. It doesn’t mean that the person is not looking at the report and it’s just these are the numbers. No, now the person is explaining the report and has more time. Instead of just gathering the data, then the marketer is actually able to build on top of the data all the reasoning behind it. And we see this for small businesses as well.

    for our customers. if you let’s say you’re a plumber, you’re repairing a sink and your phone rings, you need to answer that second customer, but you’re not. So you’re just gonna keep your phone in your pocket, wait until you finish the job to call back the customer. What if you had an AI receptionist that can answer the phone for you and look at your calendar automatically and book your next job?

    I don’t know again a lot of plumbers who like to book jobs themselves, they prefer just repairing the leak that their customers have in their bathroom. And this is how we suggest our customers to use AI and to incorporate within the way they work and within their operations how they can actually get the fullest of AI for their business.

    John Jantsch (06:34.211)

    So how does somebody go about, especially a a firm that doesn’t maybe have people that feel like they’re very tech savvy or, you know, kind of on the cutting edge? somebody’s got to redesign some of these processes. Somebody has to show, you know, how this AI is going to integrate in it. Is that should they is that a different person? Like do they need to go out and hire somebody new, hire some third party you know, resources or consultants to actually come and install it? And

    So that’s half the question. And the other half though is there’s a whole lot of people out there selling, you know, run your business with AI. you know, and and so, you know, how does a small business owner, first off, get that outside expertise and how they know that they’re not just being sold, you know, the latest, greatest get rich scheme.

    Jeremy Jarry (07:23.19)

    Yes, so I think that there are really different ways of approaching it and looking at how AI can actually help your business. And it’s not necessarily you need to be AI native, you need to have AI agents for your business. It’s really about if you don’t have the knowledge, and we actually did a survey to

    Over 2,000 of our customers and we asked them, Do you use AI in your business? And if not, why don’t you use AI in your business? And we thought all the small businesses are are gonna tell us it’s because of the cost, right? It there’s a lot of cost pressure at the moment. And we thought this is gonna be the biggest answer on why they’re not using AI. And it was actually not. It was actually a knowledge gap. And our customers told us it’s

    John Jantsch (08:06.587)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (08:17.99)

    Yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (08:20.202)

    It’s scary, it’s intimidating to see all the changes that are currently happening with AI, and it’s hard to keep up to date with it. And we provide some AI-powered tools. So we know a lot of small business owners want to change their website, for example. And so we give them a tool that is powered by AI to actually change their business. But we also understand that for small businesses.

    John Jantsch (08:26.298)

    Mm-hmm.

    Jeremy Jarry (08:49.194)

    And small business owners, it’s not they don’t really care if we use AI or not in that. They care about the results. They care about is it actually saving them time? And again, for a website, we know a lot of small businesses are looking at their website and thinking, I need to change it. I just don’t have the time. But AI is actually helping them to change it faster. For your second part of the question, and

    John Jantsch (08:57.628)

    Mm-hmm.

    Jeremy Jarry (09:18.634)

    Also, a bit of the the first part. should they hire AI consultants? if it’s what they need? Yes, sure. But I think there’s a lot of tools out there that are very easy to get a grip on and that can introduce you to AI and where you can understand the different possibilities that AI can offer your business. And it’s also very easy to

    Write an email now with AI. And it doesn’t mean that you shouldn’t write what you should say. If I tell ChatGPT or Claude, write an email for John. An email about what? So we still need to tell AI this is what I want. This is what I want you to, the outcome I want. And then I get AI to actually help me to go faster or to

    John Jantsch (10:00.891)

    Mm-hmm.

    John Jantsch (10:14.372)

    Okay.

    Jeremy Jarry (10:14.688)

    write something, for example, that is without spelling mistakes, where you know you’re on the go on your phone, it’s easy to make spelling mistakes, use AI, and it’s a lot easier to actually do it this way.

    John Jantsch (10:28.294)

    So when you were going through this process and reworking some of the things on your own, where where did it break down? I mean, where did you find people that just reverted back to the kind of the the habit, so to speak, of just using the tools, but not really changing anything?

    Jeremy Jarry (10:44.95)

    Yes, so we knew when we started that it would be a long process. So first when we started doing it, we gave ourselves and to the team a lot of time to really embrace AI, make changes, and we did it step by step. We also hired the team to help us to teach us AI, but also to help us rewire all our processes.

    And we saw that some people were very quick and very happy about using AI. Well, then there were other people that would take more time, and we actually gave them the time and we’ve let them go back to their process, understand that maybe the results were lower than when they were using AI, or that they were doing things at a lower pace than when they were using AI.

    And I think everyone by themselves understood, but if I do this, I can be like my teammate, I can actually spend more time doing things that I like. In the marketing team, we have very talented people who are very creative, but spending half or more than half of their times building a report, writing a slide, it’s not really what they want and what they like. And they saw that.

    Other people in the company were actually being super creative and they had a lot of time to do that. And so, bit by bits, I think every team member actually got into using more AI. And even today, we can see that we have some team members who are managing a fleet of agents while some other people are more using AI here and there to actually get better results or go faster, but not necessarily.

    Building AI agents themselves or managing AI agents.

    John Jantsch (12:43.899)

    Yeah. So it’s it’s become pretty common, whether anybody knows what this means or not, it’s become pretty common advice to keep a human in the loop. you know, that’s actually like you know, you pretty much can’t read anything that talks about using AI that doesn’t have that as somewhere as part of the advice. What does that actually mean? you know, for for you guys.

    Jeremy Jarry (13:09.804)

    Yes, so the way we’ve designed AI and and our AI infrastructure is we have all the data and all the knowledge from the marketing team that is centralized. And so we’re asking AI every time it has to complete a task that we’re asking to go and ask this central base of knowledge to

    make sure that it’s not gonna be drifting from our brand guidelines, from our tone of voice. But it will. And there is a risk. And so we always need to have some steps where we mitigate that risk, but also where we check. I wouldn’t let AI publish a campaign without the team members actually looking over and understanding.

    John Jantsch (13:44.059)

    Mm-hmm.

    Jeremy Jarry (14:06.048)

    making sure every asset is actually pixel perfect on what we launch. And it’s the same in any department in Boukepi, where we wouldn’t let AI do things that are risky for the business.

    John Jantsch (14:22.917)

    Did you have any speaking of that, I guess, did you have any processes that you rolled out, you revamped and then you had to kind of take back? Like once you started measuring it and measuring maybe how it impacted potential customer interaction? were there any that you decided, hey, we need to we need to lessen the role of AI in this and maybe re up the the role of the human?

    Jeremy Jarry (14:46.306)

    Yes, and for us using AI is about results. it’s I think at the beginning it was very exciting and we started building a lot of agents. And we were measuring the results by the number of agents that we would build on a specific week. But we saw very rapidly that didn’t really equate to the number of hours that were saved for the company. Or

    John Jantsch (14:51.087)

    Yep.

    John Jantsch (14:56.707)

    Right. Yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (15:14.326)

    that we were seeing some increases in the revenue that we were generating. And so definitely we saw some processes that we had where we were going way too far with AI and we couldn’t see actually that it was saving time. Building an agent and having, as we spoke about, a human in the loop. We need to make sure that the time that the human is actually gonna spend.

    To review the campaign is actually less than the time it would take them to actually create a campaign from scratch themselves. So definitely we’ve had these issues and we fell into that. And for some of the processes, we had to tone back and rethink again the process for having humans actually building the whole thing.

    John Jantsch (15:51.675)

    For sure. Yeah.

    John Jantsch (16:10.031)

    You know, one of things that that I think is probably a little frustrating for some people is the change, the pace of change in AI. and so we build all these processes and then really the the way the tools work or you know what they integrate with now maybe eliminates the need for other tools, things like that. How do you is there a rhythm for kind of staying on top of the the fact that you’re never done?

    Jeremy Jarry (16:35.638)

    Yes, it it is very daunting. and the pace is is definitely very high. the way we see it is do we always need to be on the complete cutting edge of all the technology? most of the times we do not. we actually do have some automations and some AI agents giving us, you know.

    John Jantsch (16:36.677)

    Yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (17:04.386)

    These are the latest models, these are the latest tools that exist. But that that doesn’t mean that we actually need them. And that doesn’t mean that we would actually integrating them do a better job. So the way we see it is: are we satisfied with the process? Do we have another process that we actually need to change with AI? And for that new process, would it make sense to add a different tool or

    removing one of the tools that we have. But you’re right, it’s very difficult to keep up the pace with all the different things.

    John Jantsch (17:39.279)

    Yeah, yeah. So so tell us a little bit, how does bookkeeping work with small business owners? Give us kind of the the overview of of basically what you do and how you provide value to small business owners.

    Jeremy Jarry (17:55.044)

    Yeah, so we started a few years ago with invoicing. our founder was a tradie himself, and he understood that it was difficult for him to just invoice his customers all the time, at soon as he would finish the job. So he built an invoicing app. And that was actually the beginning of the end of the process where you do have.

    John Jantsch (18:03.301)

    Yeah, yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (18:24.665)

    To invoice your customers, but also you need to get new customers. So, how do I get new customers? I’m I’m a Tyler and it’s not my strength to actually acquire new customers. So step by step, we actually built products around invoice. And so we now have a lot of different tools to help small businesses from

    Building a website, sending a proposal, creating a contract, sending an NDA, following all the processes within your CRM, sending an invoice and then getting paid.

    John Jantsch (19:07.703)

    Awesome. Well, again, I appreciate you stopping by Duct Tape Marketing Podcast, Jeremy. Is there some place you’d invite people to find out more about bookkeeping and and connect with you?

    Jeremy Jarry (19:19.053)

    Yes, they can go on our website at pukeep.com. and they can follow me on Twitter or on LinkedIn and I would encourage them also to listen to the Ductate podcast.

    John Jantsch (19:34.523)

    I I second that. Jeremy again, I appreciate you stopping by and I know it’s you’re you’re in a different time zone than me, so I pr hopefully hopefully I didn’t keep you up too get you up too early or keep you up too late.

    Jeremy Jarry (19:37.263)

    Yeah.

    Jeremy Jarry (19:48.118)

    It was a pleasure being with you, John.